Fix the damn roads

Preached on the Twenty-fifth Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 28A), November 15, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Stephen Crippen.

Zephaniah 1:7, 12-18
Psalm 90:1-8, 12
1 Thessalonians 5:1-11
Matthew 25:14-30

Parable of the Talents, stained glass at the Church of St. Edith in Yorkshire, England

We have a lot of work to do.

But first, a little celebration. Last week, watching the election returns, I breathed a sigh of relief on behalf of our most vulnerable companions across this nation. I felt a deep, energizing feeling of satisfaction on behalf of undocumented neighbors who live in fear, and on behalf of the friends and family of Renee Good, Alex Pretti, and other victims of state-sponsored oppression and violence. I rejoiced on behalf of this living planet, now that authentic hope has returned that this nation might once again stand alongside other highly industrialized nations as they work to halt and reverse climate change. 

But then I thought this, when I held in my mind and heart all of the newly elected public servants who swept into power last week: I thought, “Okay, now we have to get stuff done.”

We have a lot of work to do.

And the “we” here is not the Democratic Party. The “we” here is not just progressive Christians. The “we” here is not just those who were elected to public office. Last week I saw a photo of a beaming senator-elect shaking the hand of his predecessor, someone who had lost his party’s primary and is now on his way out of politics. The outgoing senator looked like I do when overwhelming social pressure is demanding that I smile, but inwardly I want to sob, or throw a fit, or just look out the window and quietly mourn over joys departed. I imagined the old senator thinking to himself, “This photo op is almost over.” But what’s not over is the fact that even as a lame-duck public servant heading home to retirement, he has a lot of work to do.

We all have a lot of work to do.

Speaking of politicians, I’ve always liked the campaign slogan of a candidate who ran successfully some years ago for governor of Michigan: her slogan was, “Fix the damn roads.” Yes. We Christians have been trained by our forebears in faith not to expect much from human governments and human politicians, but it’s not too much to expect them to fix the damn roads, literally and otherwise. Secure adequate health insurance for all people: fix that damn road. Ensure that women and girls have full access to reproductive health care: fix that damn road. Protect the rights and dignity of trans and nonbinary persons: fix that damn road. Conduct yourselves with honesty and courage on the world stage, for the sake of Palestinian children and Israeli children, for Ukrainian and Russian children, for Sudanese and South Sudanese children, for Taiwanese and Chinese children, for Iranian and American children, for the sake of everyone’s children, because everyone’s children are everyone’s children: fix that damn road!

The politicians all have a lot of work to do.

But back to our mission, our faith, our purpose here, today and all days: we too have a long list of tasks to get done. Jesus drives this point home for us in a knotty and troubling parable about the end times. (Knotty and troubling parables are a specialty of Matthew the evangelist.) 

You’ve just heard this parable. After hearing it, you may have paused before sputtering, “Praise to you, Lord Christ?”. The parable is dry-eyed and savvy about how the world works. It’s rough. It speaks of an angry master who mercilessly punishes a slave.

We need to be careful how we interpret this parable. Please know that the harsh master of the household is not Jesus: look past a simple allegory. The parable is a complicated way for Jesus to indirectly teach us a bracing lesson. Yes, we are roughly analogous to the slaves in the parable, but in the eye of God we are not indentured servants in an unjust economic system, and God is not a temperamental lord who casts us into the outer darkness. The rough imagery and stern commands in the parable are there just to show us how dead-serious Jesus is about the importance of his mission, the importance of all the work we have to do. The parable should jolt us awake.

Let’s begin to unpack this parable by reflecting on the “talents” in the story. A talent is a huge amount of money: five talents is the value of a century of one laborer’s wages. But this is not a parable about financial wealth, whatever you might have heard from bad preachers over the years who misinterpret the whole thing as prosperity gospel, a heresy that asserts God’s preference for wealthy people. No. The talents are our responsibilities, our task lists. The talents are the work we have to do. The unworthy slave, by burying his small task list, essentially fails to fix the damn roads, so the master, in deep frustration, gives that slave’s tasks to the hardest and most productive worker. 

Notice again the stern urgency in this parable, the immense importance of the tasks that need to be done, the high value the master places on hard work. He reacts angrily to the slave who shirks his duty, but the anger isn’t about his intemperate personality, or his casual abuse of power. It’s about his anxiety that the work of the kingdom is not being done.

Notice also how we aren’t all expected to have equal capacity for fixing the damn roads. One “talent” of work is plenty to do, and if that servant had simply worked on his projects, a fifth the size of the most productive servant, he would have been found worthy. Your enough is enough.

Now reflect on your own work in the kingdom, on the mission, in the current circumstances of your life, and our common life here. Perhaps you are well advanced in years, and you are focused on your own health and safety, and rightly so. You may not have a lot of labor to offer your community at this point in your life, and that is good and right: you are an elder, and your role has shifted as you bear the burdens – and the gifts – of your many years among us. In a real sense you shouldn’t take on two or five ‘talents’ of labor in the kingdom. You are supposed to support us on the mission with your wise presence and your faithful prayers.

Perhaps you are only two or four years old, on the other side of human life. In that case, your labor is slight indeed. Your job is to play, to shout out with excitement when the rest of us are holding solemn silence, to delight your family and friends with your simple and joyful existence. You are an exuberant theologian, but you don’t write treatises or act out your faith in prophetic works of justice: you are only four years old! You simply exist to embody God’s own words at the creation, when God saw the creatures of every kind and proclaimed them very good.

When a small child comes to the Table for Communion, I sometimes am just stopped in my tracks, bearing simple witness to the lovely presence of pure gladness in our midst. Not much labor for these little ones. That will come later.

And then there are the rest of us on the long arc of human life, in adolescence, young adulthood, middle age, and the autumn years of the sixties and seventies. We have more to do. There are weeks when I feel like I was given five talents to manage. There are days when I wonder whether our curate really takes her day off every week. There are days when I worry about a faith leader or two in this parish – I worry that they are out in the vineyard from dawn to dusk, taking on more than five, maybe more than ten, huge ‘talents’ of responsibility.

But there are natural and proper variances in the number of talents one or another adult might have. This is not a prosperity parable but it also is not an ableist one. Some of us receive one talent of responsibilities, and that is plenty. The lesson is not to work more, or work as much as your neighbor. The lesson is to not bury your treasure. Don’t get smaller. Don’t suppress or ignore the power of your presence, the value of your labor in this vineyard, no matter its size or complexity.

Yesterday I came to one of our parish work parties, and this was a first for me. Across four years here as your rector, these parties always fell on Saturdays when I was already scheduled to do something else. This time I showed up. Yay, me. But I confess I did not do much more than one proverbial talent of work. I hauled two wheelbarrows full of mulch and spread the mulch over a section of the garden. I helped clear off the debris on our trash enclosure. I talked to other volunteers, I hope in a way that encouraged and thanked them. I offered assistance to a neighbor in need of our discretionary funds. Then I had to leave for another appointment, so I missed lunch with the others.

Later yesterday afternoon — I confess: after a half-hour nap — I opened our camera app to see who was still on site. I saw Chris Magnusson, junior warden; Daphne Monary-Ernsdorff, one of our 8:00am-mass faith leaders; and Andrew Stone, team lead for Communion bread bakers. Tim Douglass and Pippa Stoddard stayed late too. Deborah Cushing, Joe McDermott, BJ Ohlweiler, Catharine Reid, Helen Roll, Jeremy Whalen, Connor Yeutter, Damon Yeutter… They all worked hard, investing their talents to support our mission, adding beauty to this green earth, shedding grace and blessing upon this busy urban corner.

All of those who came and worked yesterday — they’re a lot like all the rest of you. We all have various responsibilities, set to us by God for the life of the world. So our way forward is clear: we shouldn’t duck our duties; we shouldn’t bury our treasure of skillful labor alongside each other on this mission.

Our way forward is clear: let’s go and fix the damn roads.

Replenishing Oil in Apocalyptic Uncertainty

Preached on The Twenty-Fourth Sunday after Pentecost (Year A), November 8, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Kelly Moody.

Amos 5:18-24
Psalm 70
1 Thessalonians 4:13-18
Matthew 25:1-13

Oil in Her Lamp, by Jenny Komenda

I have a smartwatch that tracks my sleep, among other things. It tells me how long I rested, what the quality of my sleep was, and other interesting patterns of data. But these days I find that I’m more attached to the metric than I would like to be. If the sleep score is bad, I’m disappointed, even though it’s perfectly normal to have a rough night here and there. If the metric is good, I feel that I’ve accomplished something, even though all I did was sleep. Information like this can be useful of course, but there’s so much more to pay attention to about the quality and impact of sleep than the numbers on my watch.   

And that’s what I want to explore with you this morning: the dissonance that can come with knowledge. We can know so many things now with relative ease.  We can search the entire internet in seconds, ask google anything we can’t remember.  No need to trek to the library during business hours anymore to find the most updated encyclopedia when you’re curious about something.  Can’t remember what time the post office opens?  Google it. Wondering who the coach of the Baltimore Ravens is now?  You know what to do.  No worries about missing that event– it was recorded, and you can watch it anytime. Your lab reports came back?  Who needs a doctor, drop those numbers into ChatGPT and see what they mean!¹

The point is, all of this knowledge is so easily accessible, but I am not sure it has made our lives better.  I don’t think it has expanded our perspectives or made us more compassionate to people who are not like us.  On the contrary, I think access to so much information can lead us into a false sense of certainty. Because for all the superficial knowledge we can access, there are many things we cannot know, at least not like this. How will our health change in the next twelve months? Who are our neighbors, and how can we love them? Where are our habits and consumption out of line with our values, and what motivates us to change them?  

Knowledge alone, and the speed with which we can access it, is not enough to live a just and holy life. We need discernment.  We need humility and companionship. We need the wisdom of God. 

In Jesus’s parable, all ten bridesmaids have knowledge about an upcoming wedding. But none of them know when the wedding will be.  Five bridesmaids get ready to wait for an uncertain amount of time; they brought extra oil. Five had the certainty of the wedding alone. Maybe they googled “how to prepare to meet the bridegroom,” and there was no mention of bringing extra oil.  I don’t know, but they weren’t prepared to wait. 

Notice that all ten of them fell asleep. But the five who had found a way to sit in the uncertainty were able to enter into a new reality with the bridegroom when he finally arrived, while the other five remained in the old reality, unable to enter in. 

Now I want to pause here and say that I know it can be tempting to get hung up on the bridegroom’s seemingly callous behavior in this story, or to advocate in righteous anger for those poor bridesmaids who were shut out of the celebration.  But I wonder, if this parable is not about having access to all the insider information, what could it be about?  

What if it is about cultivating a way of being with the unknown?  Keeping the light burning in the darkness of uncertainty²? What if the oil is how we stay connected to God when justice is delayed, and disappointment comes, or questions loom large? 

The Gospel of Matthew was likely written down after the fall of the Temple in Jerusalem, for a community whose world had turned upside down.  So many sure and certain powers were coming to an end, and in their wake there was instability, but there was also freedom to imagine a new world order. How would they live in the midst of that kind of upheaval?  What had Jesus taught them that could help them make sense of the times, and live into the possibilities for justice and righteousness?  You’ll hear some of Jesus’s takes over the course of the next few Sundays, as we explore the apocalyptic texts of these last chapters in Matthew. They can be hard to parse, but the world into which they spoke was marked by at least as much chaos and confusion as ours is. 

Later in Christian tradition, saints like Benedict of Nursia distilled Jesus’s words about how to live with apocalyptic uncertainty into wisdom for everyday life.  Benedict was born about 70 years after the fall of Rome. So he, too, was well-acquainted with late-stage empire dynamics, and the uncertainty they can create. Benedict’s deep conviction was that God’s presence was everywhere, so everything one did could be offered as a prayer; a collaboration with God.  He designed a rule of life that taught people to listen for God and be open to hearing God’s guidance moment by moment. And in responding to God’s guidance over time, Benedict believed we would be transformed into more loving, Christ-like people.   

Benedict’s way of living, was oriented around three core principles: prayer, obedience, and conversion of life. Maybe a better way of saying it for our postmodern minds would be prayerfulness, or listening with the ear of our hearts; responsiveness to God’s Spirit, and a willingness to turn toward the doors God opens in our lives³.  Living like this requires us to pay attention differently to the world around us. Instead of scouring it for information and data we can use, we are to be still and listen, attending even to the silences and absences around us⁴. We are to invite God’s attention to help us make sense of things. 

This threefold rule for attentive living is like extra oil for a lamp that burns in a dark night.  It anchors us to the presence of God in the midst of uncertainty and superficiality. Being aware of God and God’s desires as we go about our lives in this uncertain world is not knowledge we can google or track on a smartwatch.  There are no metrics…no obvious rewards.  It’s simply a daily practice of paying attention, and inviting Jesus to pay attention in and through us.  

For Benedict, the frequency of our turning toward God was far more important than getting the words or rituals just right. Each time we turn to God and ask for guidance, Benedict believed that wisdom would grow within us. Maybe you could say the oil in our lamp is replenished. And as we practice paying attention with God in ordinary moments, we develop the ability to recognize Christ among us in the most unexpected places. This is how we are made ready to participate in the new reality of justice and righteousness he is ushering in right here, in the middle of the chaos and confusion of our world.  

So the next time you begin to google something, or check a number on your smartwatch, I encourage you to pause first, and remember the presence of Christ. Invite his attention into the moment. Maybe this simple practice will enable us to sit with the Unknown just a little longer, and discover new ways to keep the light burning for all people in the midst of apocalyptic uncertainty. 

I’d like to close with a prayer:

Almighty God, by whose grace St. Benedict, kindled with the fire of your love, became a burning and a shining light in the church: inflame us with the same spirit of discipline and love, that we may walk before you as children of light; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen⁵. 

_________________________________________________

¹  I do not actually recommend this!
² https://streetpsalms.org/proper-27-32-year-a/
³ See chapter 72 of the Benedictine rule of life. There are a few Benedictine monastic communities in the United States, including St. John’s Abbey in Minnesota, The Community of St. Mary in Sewanee, The Order of the Holy Cross in New York, and St. Gregory’s Abbey in Michigan. Check out their websites for resources and retreats.
⁴ To read more about respect for silence in Benedictine religious communities, see Chapter 42 of the rule. Many thanks to Sister Egeria Mark at the Community of St. Mary, Southern Province in Sewanee, TN for helping me articulate Benedict’s ideas in this sermon! 
⁵ This is an older version of the prayer, taken from Esther de Waal’s excellent book, Seeking God: The Way of St. Benedict.  The updated prayer for Benedict’s feast in Lesser Feasts and Fasts, 2024 is as follows: “Gracious God, whose service is perfect freedom and in whose commandments there is nothing harsh nor burdensome: Grant that we, with your servant Benedict, may listen with attentive minds, pray with fervent hearts, and serve you with willing hands, so that we might live at peace with one another and in obedience to your Word, Jesus Christ our Lord, who with you and the Holy Spirit lives and reigns, one God, now and for ever. Amen.”

Anamnetic Connections

Preached on The Commemoration of All Faithful Departed (Year A), November 3, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Kelly Moody.

Wisdom 3:1–9
Psalm 130
1 Thessalonians 4:13–18
John 5:24-27

Light of The Candle, by Melani Pyke

One day in the future, some of you may very well look back on these days, in early November of 2026, and say, “you know, those were the good old days.” Perhaps you will say it as you recall the souls around you now with gratitude, and long to be with them once more. Or when a child in your life crosses a graduation stage, and tears swell in your eyes because you can hear the sound of their voice when they were 3-years-old, you might find yourself saying it then.Or perhaps tonight you might find yourself recalling an earlier period in your life, when someone you loved was still alive. 

Perhaps you still recall the texture of their coat, or the smell of their cologne, or the safety you felt in their presence. Scientists who study memory call this nostalgia. It is a sweet human experience, warm, sometimes aching with longing.  

It is a good and holy thing to return these moments. Nostalgia is often stirred here at church, through familiar smells and sounds, returning us to a memory in the past that’s blessedly free from the friction of nitty gritty details.

But nostalgic memory is not all we are left with when time passes, and our beloveds die. 

We Christians are not merely nostalgic for Jesus and his last Supper, or for those who are no longer with us.  Rather, we proclaim a present connection through the resurrected Christ; an eternal moment, reaching forward and backward in time simultaneously.

Christians are communities of Jesus-followers gathered across time and space, life and death, and into a communion that transcends any single gathering in history alone. When we celebrate the Eucharist, we are stepping through our temporal experience into the eternal reality of Christ’s resurrected life with all the faithful departed, and all that are yet to come. 

 Paul describes in his letter to the Thessalonians how the braiding together of temporal experiences and eternal realities should comfort us when our friends and loved ones die. He says, “We do not want you to be uninformed, brothers and sisters, about those who have died, so that you may not grieve as others do who have no hope. For since we believe that Jesus died and rose again, through Jesus, God will bring with him those who have died.” They will be among us, and we among them, in the Body of Christ. 

The kind of memory that Christians engage in when we remember Jesus’s death is not nostalgia, but Anamnesis. Anamnesis is a fancy word for describing how we, as people who follow Jesus now, are joined to those who have followed Jesus throughout the ages 

through the Paschal mystery we proclaim each time we pray at this altar. So we are not merely  calling to mind what happened a long time ago, or what his death meant in its historical context. We are entering into it now, experiencing it in the context of our lives. Sacramental worship is the Church’s effective proclamation of God’s mighty acts and promises eternally- acts and promises, completed in the past, but whose impacts are still unfolding among us. 

These eternal moments  shape our capacity for relationship, even with those who have died. We weren’t there physically thousands of years ago when Jesus taught the disciples, and yet we know his voice. We didn’t sit at the table with him then, and yet we receive his hospitality here.  We didn’t see his healing miracles ourselves, and yet we are healed as he becomes known to us in bread and wine. Events in the past come forward into the present and come to bear on our lives today, even in the nitty gritty details.  And these encounters give us hope, not merely nostalgia for a moment in time that has slipped away. 

I spent a lot of my early life with my grandmother when I was growing up.  My mom worked evening and night shifts at the hospital, so my grandmother would pick me up from school, take me to my after-school activities, make me dinner, teach me to say my prayers, and put me to bed. My grandmother was just a delightful person to be around.  She was spunky and joyful, anxious about small things, yet completely fearless when danger struck. She was the most faithful person I knew, and her love for me was fierce. 

After a long, slow decline with Alzheimer’s disease, my grandmother entered hospice in the spring of 2011. I flew home to Nashville with two small children in tow and sat at her bedside for days on end, recalling the goodness of our ordinary life together.  

She didn’t always remember me.  

Her agitation came in waves, and when it did, she would try to get out of bed and get away from the misery she was in. 

My nostalgia couldn’t reach her then. 

The only thing that settled her, for a moment anyway, was prayer. Recalling the presence of Christ in songs and prayers soothed her. Those days were difficult to bear witness to. The nitty-gritty details of death often are.  But they were underscored by something truer than the pain; something greater than the number of times I had to remind her who I was: The death and resurrection of Jesus: already complete, yet still unfolding in their impact. The presence of Christ, made known to my grandmother over and over again,until she could finally let go. 

There is a difference between nostalgia for the past, sweet though it may be,  and the hope we proclaim in Christ. That hope is an anchor for the whole of our lives. Every nitty-gritty detail of it, all the way until the end. 

So do not grieve as others do who have no hope. Jesus is with all those who have died, and by his resurrection, Jesus is with all of us who are still alive.We remain in communion through him…and together, we long for the full revelation of death’s defeat. 

Blessed are those who mourn

Preached on All Saints’ Day (Year A), November 1, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Stephen Crippen.

Revelation 7:9-17
Psalm 34:1-10, 22
1 John 3:1-3
Matthew 5:1-12

All Saints (detail), by Jean Colombe

Blessed are those who mourn, for they will be comforted.
God will wipe away every tear from their eyes.

I would like to read a poem by Jane Kenyon, called What Came to Me:

I took the last
dusty piece of china
out of the barrel.
It was your gravy boat,
with a hard, brown
drop of gravy still
on the porcelain lip.
I grieved for you then
as I never had before.

I would like to read it for you again.

I took the last
dusty piece of china
out of the barrel.
It was your gravy boat,
with a hard, brown
drop of gravy still
on the porcelain lip.
I grieved for you then
as I never had before.

If we are honest, we will admit that we mourn our beloved dead a lot more than we mourn bigger losses or catastrophes like the hell of war or the outrage of systemic violence. Our own personal losses, our own heart-shattering bereavements — these are reliably more important to us. Of course we are personally ethical and morally awake, so we do lament the atrocious absence of justice on earth, and we do nod along as a well-meaning preacher reminds us that when our Savior said, “Blessed are those who mourn, for they will be comforted,” Jesus wasn’t talking about how I miss my parents, he was talking about big-picture grief — the mourning of those who suffer injustice and oppression. Yes, of course, Jesus. We hear you.

But then, every time, we focus first on personal grief. Surely you know this. Surely you agree. 

And so: The world is roiling in crisis and war, but… I miss my daddy. I want my mommy. I am fifty-six years old and I have great strength, and I have gone to therapy for years, but deep in my heart — and honestly, it’s not all that deep, you can find it within moments of searching — in my broken heart, the little boy still living in there just wants his parents, and he cannot be consoled in the terrible absence of their familiar warmth and intensity and delight. The little boy in me would even welcome a hard word from either parent, even though he always hated those words, always hated getting in trouble. If they came back to scold me, I would welcome them. I miss them.

Surely you miss your beloved dead. You want them. How could you not? I expect you also tremble at the thought of losing more people, or losing your own life. We are strong and we are mighty, good people of God, but we are also fragile, and sometimes frail. I have a stout heart and a courageous gut and a creative brain, but one day all of these fleshy organs will cease, they will fall silent, and I will be gone from this good, green earth. And so will you.

Can our faith bear the weight of all this grief? Can our faith take it, hold it, share the burden, hold us firm like a good heavy chair with a straight back, formed of hardwood by a skillful craftsman? Can Jesus take us, hold us, share the burden, hold us firm? 

Can Mary Magdalene? When Mary Magdalene bravely walked into the resurrection garden and wept without apology before a mysterious stranger, she hallowed all graveyards, and she hallowed all grief. Surely Mary Magdalene understands that our hearts are more likely to break for our own beloved dead than a mighty saint who dies after a life of wondrous words and prophetic acts. Surely Mary Magdalene, weeping openly — ugly-crying — in the presence of the Risen One will be our faith leader and help us make sense of loss, and find hope. She is so much like us: She cried not because the head of the Jesus Movement was killed. She cried because her friend died.

So she gets it. Mary Magdalene is a person who understands things.

But she is not the only Mary who can come to our aid. Mary the mother of Jesus has a ravaged heart, pierced seven times by stinging sorrow — and it was sorrow she saw coming, sorrow she anticipated.

But the Marys are hardly alone, hardly the only people in the pub who can cry in their beer alongside us. 

All the saints know grief. Saint Jude prays to God for all who have hopeless causes, and that finally is all of us, for we are “mortal, formed of the earth, and to earth we shall return.” Saint Paul writes feverishly, letter after letter, counseling and consoling the churches as they battle the dragons of Sin and Death. Saint Peter staggers from the campfire in backbreaking remorse, and comes out of his crisis as a chastened and self-aware apostle, on the road to his own cross of crucifixion. Saint John won’t stop talking about how we should abide with Christ, how salvation is not getting free passage into heaven, no, salvation is abiding in the here and now with the Risen One in painful, grievous intimacy, washing one another’s feet.

The saints get it. The saints are people who understand things.

The saints know that this community, this parish — the saints know that we have a body count, a body count that is ever rising. We just lost our companion Marilynne. Marilynne! She is so lovely, so diligent, so careful, so particular. I love her, and I’m sure every one of you who knows her loves her. Why can’t we see her? Her holy death after a well-lived life may be easier to accept than catastrophic or violent deaths, but her departure is no less grievous to us.

Grief is grief.

Again, the saints come to our aid as we mourn. And here is how they do that. They meet us at the flowing water that is at the edge of our hearing, flowing day and night in the entryway behind you. We turned the heater on yesterday so that when we plunge poor Quinn, another vulnerable mortal, formed of the earth, into the water, she will not shake with cold. And the saints meet us there. The saints crowd the riverbank; they walk up and down the beach; they stand firm at the roaring waterfall. They meet us at the water, in the water, over the water. Maybe they are the water.

When we are baptized — we recall this hard truth every time we do it — when we are baptized, we are baptized into Christ’s death. So we join Mary Magdalene before dawn, as she approaches the tomb, in her strong tears. We join Mary the Mother of God with her sword-riven heart. We stagger from the dying campfire with Peter; we labor with anxiety and determination alongside Paul; we recline with John in the upper room and watch with wonder as Christ himself takes our feet in his hands; we plead to God with Jude for all who go down to the dust. We are deep in the water with all the saints.

And in this washing and swimming and drowning, in this whirl of the rushing water of life, our mourning expands. We still miss Marilynne, and yelp with agony at the senseless deaths of innocents, and cry out for those we love but see no longer; and our mourning expands: whirling in the baptismal waters, we embrace more and more people in need of friendship and compassion and advocacy; we confront more and more injustices that demand our presence and power; we take in the whole universe of struggle and suffering, and heed the call of our Savior to lend everyone our aid. 

Like all the saints, our mentors in grieving, we don’t stay stuck in lament and mourning. We get up, and we take Quinn with us, her forehead marked forever with the cross of Christ, and we announce Resurrection to the others. We run to them, frantic with joy as well as grief, and, breathless from our run, still gasping with both sorrow and wonder, we encourage all who are suffering by singing to them, with gladness:

Look upon the Lord and be radiant,
and let not your faces be ashamed.

You have what it takes

Preached on the 22nd Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 25A), October 25, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Stephen Crippen.

Leviticus 19:1-2, 15-18
Psalm 1
1 Thessalonians 2:1-8
Matthew 22:34-46

Love Wall, by James Goldcrown

Let’s talk about our guts. We’re told often enough to trust our guts, to follow our guts. We do gut checks. We get gut aches. Sometimes we suffer a gut punch.

What’s a gut check? It's when you stop and consider your instinctive feelings or notions about something. 

A gut ache? Well, there’s the literal kind, how you feel if you overindulge on pizza, but there’s also the gut ache of agitation, a persistent worry, a burning emotional sensation.

A gut punch? That’s when you’re knocked over by bad news, or sharp conflict, or overwhelming fear. “I was gutted,” people sometimes say, after hearing terrible news.

What does your gut tell you? How does your gut feel? You probably know a few things about your physical gut, to set all metaphors aside for a moment. Your physical gut is filled with helpful bacteria, numbering in the uncountable billions, responsible for much of your health and well-being. And your gut is the path to the exit for waste, toxins, all the yucky stuff that your body no longer needs, all the disgusting stuff that could poison your body if it can’t find a way out.

We don’t think or talk about our guts very much, here in church. We seem to stand on ceremony here, in polite company, and we instinctively know that guts are… gross. So instead we talk about love, and we talk about remorse, passion, and compassion: strong feelings, these! We talk about anger and fear, frustration and longing, anxiety and despair. It is far less common for us to explore the messy parts of our bodies where many of these feelings lurk, and churn, and sometimes rush up to our hearts and out of our mouths, for good and for ill.

First-century Christians may have been more attuned than we are to matters of the gut. When we hear him today, Jesus, in today’s Good News according to Matthew, doesn’t seem to mention the gut. He quotes the greatest commandment in the Torah in this way: “You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind.” But in the sixth chapter of Deuteronomy, the source text that Jesus is using, the commandment is worded differently: instead of loving the Lord our God with all our heart, soul, and mind, we are to love the Lord our God with all our heart, soul, and might, or strength.

But the original Hebrew word in Deuteronomy for “might” or “strength” doesn’t exactly mean “might” or “strength.” The Hebrew modeka is closer to other English words like “very,” or “exceedingly,” or “much.” So it’s more precise to translate the greatest commandment this way:

“You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your much-ness, all your very-ness, all your exceeding-ness, all your everything.” Your whole being should love the Lord your God. Your beliefs and attitudes, your desires and deepest longings, your everything-ness should love the Lord your God.

Now, consider this: in the ancient world, the gut was considered the seat of emotion, the location not only of our deepest feelings but our deepest identity. The gut, from belly to bowels, was where a person lived. It was not just where they felt things but where they found wisdom, it was where they wrestled with tough decisions. I have a gut, therefore I am.

Earlier in Matthew, Jesus is moved in his guts with compassion when he encounters people suffering from hunger or illness, or people who were lost and leaderless. Matthew’s Greek is more clearly mentioning the gut in those passages. We translate it as Jesus “feeling compassion” for the people, but it’s more accurate to say his “guts were wrenched” for them. His compassion was a gut punch.

So it’s a small leap for us, then, to conclude that Jesus and his companions understood the greatest commandment this way: “You shall love the Lord your God with your seat of feelings and wisdom, with your most essential identity, with everything that constitutes you. You shall love the Lord your God with all your gut.

But… do you? Do you love the Lord your God with your much-ness, your everything-ness, your very self, your gut? I expect that if you do, this love is not perfectly consistent. And I expect that if you do, this love will often be painful, sometimes even agonizing.

I love my husband Andrew with my gut. He is never far from my mind. When we argue, I can feel heartburn. When I haven’t heard from him and he seems to have been out walking the dogs way too long, my gut startles me with terrible ideas.

I am not a parent, but I know well how my sister feels about her boys, how all of my siblings feel about their children. You know the old saying, that having a child is like tearing your heart out of your body and letting it walk around on the earth. 

Maybe you feel this way about your career. If so, that is not shallow! Vocation is vitally important not only to the person living it, but all the people whose lives are improved by her vocation. Vocation: a word that shares a linguistic root with “voice” and “advocate.” Your vocation should wrench your gut with passion and compassion, with a heart-burning anxiety for the welfare of your neighbor; with a heartbreaking commitment to those who have no advocate but you; with a heartwarming affection for those who live without love, if not for you; with heart-opening challenges and crises that draw on every strength you have for a righteous cause.

And, ultimately, in your closest relationships, in your vocation, in all that you are and all that you do, you shall love the Lord your God: you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, with all your gut. Love for God always makes itself manifest in love for neighbor, so it is our neighbors who punch our guts with compassion; it is our neighbors who wrench our guts with outrage on their behalf; it is our neighbors who break open our hearts with the tender love of the Lord our God, who burned with love for the Israelites in bondage, the Lord God who seared the people with fiery love in the wilderness, the Lord God whose guts broke open in love for all people on the cross.

Our faith is not staid. Our faith is not meekly dutiful. Our faith is not reticent. Our faith takes guts.

Every so often, when I am out on a long run, I suffer acid reflux. It happens if I am a little dehydrated, or if I’ve slurped one of those awful energy gels with caffeine and electrolytes. But there might be another cause. I don’t talk about this too much, because I typically just want to post fitness brags about the distance I covered, or how close I am to my goals, but running, for me, is an activity that surfaces harder feelings, sadder feelings, worry thoughts. Everything is connected, so the acid reflux isn’t just the energy gel. It’s my yucky gut punches and gut wrenches that make themselves felt as I pound the asphalt.

Sometimes I play songs by Enya when I run. Friends have teased me about this: “Enya?!” they say. “Don’t you just fall asleep?!” No, Enya’s soothing harmonies and synth instruments cool me out, settle my stomach, calm my fevered imagination.

So maybe that’s why we sing so much soothing music around this place. Simple plainchant psalm refrains, gorgeous harmonies, lyrical hymns, poignant motets. Even our spoken words are soothing and musical. Even at the 8:00am mass, we are soothed and regulated by Thomas Cranmer’s masterful prayers. For St. Paul’s, these pieces of music and spoken word — they are our Enya playlist. They calm us down. They coat the acid in our guts with the soothing Word of God.

But that’s not the end of the story, for us. As we pray in one of our Eucharistic prayers, we come here not only for solace but for strength, not only for pardon but for renewal. Enya helps me calm down, but she also helps me keep running.

So: check your gut, good friends. Listen to it, and let it tell you what you care about. Let your gut show you what it means for you to love the Lord your God. Receive the Eucharist as, well, probiotics for your gut, to help you absorb the gut punches we all inevitably suffer in our life of faith — gut punches of compassion, gripping sorrow, and sharp outrage; gut punches of longing for justice. Chew a few tablets of antacid, in the form of gorgeous antiphons and soaring descants. And then: back at it. Loving the Lord our God — it takes guts.

And you have what it takes.

What do we owe God in a world like this? 

Preached on the Twenty-First Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 24A), October 18, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Kelly Moody.

Isaiah 45:1-7
Psalm 96:1-9, (10-13)
1 Thessalonians 1:1-10
Matthew 22:15-22

stars and stripes opus 1, by Carl Martham

 In 2016, NPR reported that packets of ramen noodles had usurped cigarettes as the currency of choice inside many U.S. prisons¹. Supposedly, inmates pay one another for services, like cleaning a bunk or doing another person’s laundry, using uniform and durable packets of ramen². Ramen noodles are valuable in prison because they can be eaten in one’s cell, freeing an inmate from the tyranny of terrible prison food, and offering greater freedom over when and what they eat. A locker full of soups tells you that an inmate is managing pretty well on the inside. But a locker full of ramen in any other context… well, that wouldn’t tell you much at all, would it?

Recognizing what counts as currency in any group is important information. Ramen as currency in prison systems is an example of an alternative economy that rises up whenever the conditions or values of a particular group of people collectively shift from the status quo.  In United States prisons, the adoption of ramen as currency across prison cliques, racial groups, and security levels was a functional way of expressing power and freedom in a world where both are scarce.  

So, what would you say is the currency of this Christian life we participate in together? Do we have an alternative economy? And if so, how are we to pay back to God what is God’s, as Jesus suggests in the text today? 

We find ourselves this morning once again in Matthew’s world, a violent world populated with religious hypocrites, Roman oppressors, insiders and outsiders, and one Torah-abiding Jesus who came not to abolish the law, but to fulfill it.  And Jesus’s brilliant response to the Pharisees' trap invites yet another question that Jesus doesn’t: what do we owe God? 

Like us, the Pharisees had been listening to these difficult parables Jesus was telling about vineyards and laborers and wedding garments–all material signs of doing well in the dominant economy. They could probably tell that Jesus was using these items alternatively in his parables. And theoretically, the Pharisees should have been on board with his message. After all, they were the ones living among the people in villages, and adapting Torah to the culture around them. They were the ones softening the legalism of the written law with oral tradition, and practical wisdom for ordinary people seeking to live faithfully.

And yet, Jesus’s parables offended these culturally-competent Pharisees enough to provoke them to malice. 

I think that should perplex us.

 After all, we, too, wrestle with the implications of being caught up in an unjust power structure.  We, too, are implicated in the violence and harm done by the economic and political systems in which we participate. We, too, are looking for tangible ways to live into God’s kingdom and resist the powers and principalities that pull us in a different direction. 

What do we owe God in a world like this? 

Bishop Marianne Budde says there are three possible answers to this question: 1) nothing, 2) some portion, or 3) everything³.  For those of us who hunger for the presence of God and God’s kingdom of justice and mercy, nothing cannot possibly be a satisfying  answer. Some portion is more likely, and perhaps it was the answer the Pharisees would have chosen. Some portion could look like giving each Sunday morning to the worship of God, and some percentage of our income to our church. Maybe it would include one hour a week of volunteering, or study, or prayer. It’s clearly an intentional effort, and a reasonable one. 

But it isn’t as though God only cares about some portion of our lives.  It isn’t as though God is not present among us in the other six days of our week as we work and play and care for ourselves and others. It isn’t as though God has not given us wisdom about how to spend the rest of our money and our time when we are away from church. The portion that we set aside for does not “pay off” some tax to God. 

 Living as though it does produces hypocrisy, and all of us who are trying to live in relationship to God with any sort of intention are in danger of it. 

So, answering the question of what we owe God with some portion doesn’t work, either. 

The only viable answer is everything. Everything matters to God. 

One of our Eucharistic prayers says it like this: “Fountain of life and source of all goodness, you made all things and fill them with your blessing, you created them to rejoice in the splendor of your radiance.⁴”

Everything in this world is sacred, created by God, and filled with blessing. So from the moment we wake and shuffle out of bed each day, we are to live as though that is true.  In order to give God everything, we are to live and move and have our being for the glory of God. We are to nourish and care for our bodies, expend our energy and talents at work and home, and relate to one another in companionship with God. In God’s economy, our currency is love. Love of God, loving our neighbor, love for one another, loving our enemies. Love expressed through tangible acts of care for the earth, for the communities in which we live, and for people we don’t even know. We invite Christ to dwell in us, so that all we have and all we are might reflect Christ’s love in this world. So, what we give and receive, how we relinquish privilege and reorder our common life–these are all material decisions we make with God’s help. 

I think many religious people are generally on board with this idea.  But when it comes to making material choices each day in this world’s economy to prioritize mercy and love instead of power and control, or to live as though everyone and everything is sacred and filled with God’s blessing, well, that is where the hypocrisy can creep in.

The good news is that hypocrisy is not the end of the story; not in Matthew’s world, and not in ours, either. As Christians, we trust that Jesus will strengthen us to do his will each time we ask, and each time we gather together and receive him in bread and wine, so that we can participate in God’s economy without malice or hypocrisy. What we give to God is transformed in this Eucharistic meal, and given back to us as Christ himself, who is mercy and renewal and love for the whole world. 

We owe God everything.  But God’s economy is not like the transactional economies of this world.  What God wants is not the same as what Caesar wants, and the currency is entirely different, too. In God’s alternative economy, we give freely from what we’ve been given, and we become what we receive: The gifts of God, for the people of God. 

So, may you experience the joy and freedom that comes with giving your all in God’s economy.  May you receive the strength and courage to make a material change in your life that reflects the mercy, justice, and love to which we are called. And may you experience Christ’s companionship wherever you are, inviting you ever deeper into the life of God that pulses among us everywhere. 

_________________________________________________

¹ https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2016/08/26/491236253/ramen-noodles-are-now-the-prison-currency-of-choice
² The original study was conducted by a University of Arizona student and described here: https://news.arizona.edu/news/noodles-supplant-cigarettes-prison-currency-choice
³ Read her sermon on this text in her book, Gathering Up the Fragments
⁴ Eucharistic Prayer D, found on p.373 of the Book of Common Prayer

Christ is our clothing

Preached on the Twentieth Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 23A), October 11, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Stephen Crippen.

Isaiah 25:1-9
Psalm 23
Philippians 4:1-9
Matthew 22:1-14

Saint Julian of Norwich, by Gracie Morbitzer, who visited St. Paul’s earlier this year. Prints of Morbitzer’s Julian and several other saints are on the walls of our offices.

Alright. Here’s how I see things. We could do this the easy way, or we could do this the hard way.

Saint Paul is the good cop. He offers us a carrot; he kills us with kindness. He invites us to join the challenging mission and ministry of Jesus Christ with warm greetings and sanguine encouragement. He says that we are his “joy and crown,” that he “loves and longs for” us. He wants us to “stand firm” and he encourages us to “think about” good things like “whatever is true, honorable, just, pure, pleasing, and commendable.” These are bracing exhortations! But he challenges us to do all of that while blanketing us with his gentle affection.

And he sings us a song that has sounded down the ages:

“Rejoice in the Lord always; again I will say, Rejoice. Let your gentleness be known to everyone. The Lord is near. Do not worry about anything, but in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God. And the peace of God, which surpasses all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus.”

My mother loved this passage of Scripture. She stressed two words in particular: “with thanksgiving.” “Do not worry about anything,” she would say, “but in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God.” She loved that “thanksgiving” bit. We pray for things with thanksgiving, as if our prayers have already been answered. She believed this. She encouraged it. She did not survive her affliction with ovarian cancer, and yet I believe she thought her prayers were nonetheless answered. She received the healing she truly needed. And she gave thanks for that.

So that’s the “good-cop” version of today’s Good News. Paul certainly loses his cool in other places in his letters, but in his letter to the Philippians, our patron is a cozy down comforter, stirring our souls to go from here to love and serve the Lord, all of it with tenderness and kindness and compassion. It’s a lovely vision, an encouraging approach, a good way to proclaim the Gospel.

But then there’s the bad cop.

“But when the king came in to see the [wedding] guests,” Jesus thunders in his dark parable, “[the king] noticed a man there who was not wearing a wedding robe, and he said to him, ‘Friend, how did you get in here without a wedding robe?’ And he was speechless. Then the king said to the attendants, ‘Bind him hand and foot, and throw him into the outer darkness, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth.’”

How harsh! How unnerving. How rude. How can this be Good News? We will have to unpack it. We will have to spend some time with the hard words of Jesus if we want to understand what he is saying, and saying with such passionate urgency.

First, the wedding robe. We need to know what the wedding robe might be, what it might represent. And Saint Julian of Norwich offers us an answer. Many of you know about Julian, but in case you aren’t quite sure, she was a fourteenth-century woman whose actual name is unknown to us. She lived alone in a hut attached to Saint Julian’s Church, and so, without knowing her actual name, we call this nameless solitary woman Julian.

I think you would love her. She appears in icons with a cat on her lap. Legend says she would stick her hand through a small hole in the wall to receive Eucharist from the priest in the adjoining chancel. She had visions, and her ecstasy in the presence of God was intense and joyful.

Julian wrote with feverish excitement about God as our clothing, and about us as God’s clothing. The Lutheran scholar Gail Ramshaw, a contemporary of ours who visited St. Paul’s Seattle earlier this year, says that “Julian wrote of Christ as having taken on our human tunic.” He put on our humanity, a rough tunic “‘dyed with the sweat of his body, close-fitting and short and threadbare.’” Julian then wrote that we have “received, in a merciful exchange, the cloak of Christ, that wraps us round with endless love.” 

Ramshaw then writes that “Julian… moves one step more with her image of clothing. Not only do we enjoy wearing Christ, but ‘we are his crown’; that is, Christ is wearing us. Not only are we wrapped round with the cloak of Christ, but Christ is arrayed with us.” And finally Ramshaw shares this lovely quotation from Julian: “‘Our good Lord is our clothing that, for love, wraps us up and winds us about, embracing us, all beclosing us and hanging about us, for tender love.’”

Imagine Christ as a terrycloth robe enveloping you in soft warmth. Or Christ as your favorite sweatshirt, cozy and comfortable, inspiring you to stretch out under a blanket (the blanket: that’s Christ, too) for a quiet afternoon nap. Christ as our clothing, “embracing us, all beclosing us and hanging about us, for tender love.”

Now take one more imaginative step. Christ is your wedding garment, your best outfit, the dress that makes you look healthy and lovely, and sets off your eyes; the suit that subtly complements your earrings or your necklace… or if your tastes run masculine, your boutonnière or your pocket square. Oh, you look so good in this wedding outfit! You’re dashing; you’re dazzling; you’re a knockout.

We Christians have, for centuries now, proclaimed the theological idea of Christ as our clothing in the baptismal garment, the white robe. The insider word for this robe is alb. Your altar servers wear albs, a word that simply means “white.” The alb is a sign of our baptismal identity. When we hold the cup to your lips, our white albs are our Christ-clothing, our Christ-robe, our Christ-sweatshirt, our Christ-blanket. But I hope you also take notice of this: the work we do in our Christ-clothing is the work of a servant.

And now we’re ready to return to the hard words of Jesus in today’s Good News. He scolds the wedding guest for not wearing the wedding robe, casting him out to the place where there is “weeping and gnashing of teeth.” It sounds harsh! It sounds mean and angry, not very “Jesus-y.” But this is the insight; this is the meaning of the harsh words: this wedding guest was rejecting the servant identity we share in Christ. His refusal to wear the robe rejects the challenging mission and ministry of the Risen One. 

“‘Friend, how did you get in here without a wedding robe?’” Jesus quotes the enraged king saying, and you can just hear how dangerous and ironic he sounds when he utters that word ‘friend’. (Matthew uses the very same Greek word for ‘friend’ later on when Jesus says to Judas, who is about to betray him, “Friend, do what you are here to do.”)

Confronted by the angry king, the underdressed wedding guest is rendered “speechless.” He has nothing to say to explain his refusal, or his rejection, of the Gospel. He is no better than the first people to be invited to the banquet who “made light” of the invitation, and even attacked the king’s slaves when they went to them to call them to the feast.

Clearly, the community that gave us Matthew’s Gospel is struggling with people who rejected the movement, who belittled the call to discipleship, who “made light” of the Good News. So the “bad cop” approach of Jesus today, as off-putting and even upsetting as it might be in our hearing, starts to make a little more sense. The mission matters. The Gospel is urgently needed. Jesus — and the community behind this Gospel passage — they are passionate that the Good News be proclaimed far and wide. There was so much to do. There was injustice across the land. The mission was critical.

And this remains true today. We need not wear the clothing of Christ, as lovely as it might be, and as lovely as it might make us. We might want to RSVP to this invitation with a “No, thanks.” But the world is crying out for servants richly clad in the mercy of Christ. The world is desperate for the Good News, proclaimed by people who bear on their bodies the garments of salvation, the clothing of justice, the crown of peace.

Wearing Christ as our clothing: this is a serious thing to do. The robe of Christ will change us, shape us, form us. The cloak of Christ will draw our shoulders back so that we can see and serve a person in extreme need, rather than gazing ever inward at our own needs and worries. The shoes of Christ will clasp our feet and carry us into the valleys of human suffering.

And the crown of Christ — well, I suppose if we follow Julian’s guidance carefully, the crown of Christ will be not what we wear, but what we become. We will rest on that wounded head, torn bloody with thorns. We will be worn by him. 

Nothing is more urgently needed in this world right now. This is why the king is so animated and incensed by his blasé wedding guest, a poor sod who didn’t bother to don this lovely but daunting robe of righteousness. Paul and Julian sing the Good News to us in lovely tones of reassuring encouragement. Jesus in Matthew takes a much harder tack. But I believe all three would agree that our choice to put on the clothing of Christ, versus our choice to set it aside, is a choice of immense importance. 

Will we wear this lovely but heavy garment? Will we become, in our own lives of prayer and service, the crown of Christ?

Even now this invitation is being extended to us by the Risen One, who “took on our human tunic, dyed with the sweat of his body, close-fitting and short and threadbare.”

To clarify and further extend this gracious invitation, I want to reframe the enraged king’s response to the underdressed wedding guest he sarcastically called “friend.”  I want to soften the king’s words, in the spirit of those honey-tongued saints, Paul and Julian.

I want to soften them into this: Wear the colorful, beautiful cloak of Christ, or understandably set its daunting, difficult heaviness aside. What will we choose, my good friends?

What do you want?

Preached on the Nineteenth Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 22A), October 4, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Kelly Moody.

Isaiah 5:1-7
Psalm 80:7-14
Philippians 3:4b-14
Matthew 21:33-46

Landscape with Tower in Ruin, by Thomas Cole

I want to invite you to take a deep dive into the text with me, with the help of the late French scholar René Girard, in order to explore what Jesus is doing in this parable about the vineyard and the wicked tenants¹.

Girard was a professor of French literature and history at Stanford University, and he famously articulated a “triangular theory of desire,” which is also known as mimetic theory. His  idea is that we rarely want what we want because it simply appeals to us. We want it because someone else wants it, and their desire provokes our own. Ask anyone with a sibling, and they will affirm that this is true. The entire advertising and influencing industry is based on the idea that if we see someone else wanting something,  we will want it, too.  

Maybe we never even knew that breed of dog existed, or this handbag, or that pair of shoes, but now we want it.  

Can't get it out of our minds.  

That’s mimetic theory. We want what we want because we saw someone else want it. 

But Girard also suggests that when mimetic desire creates rivalry or envy, by drawing us to desire something that is not available to us, we find release by pulling in a third party- a scapegoat- to blame, or cast out. Finding and exiling a scapegoat relieves the tension between us for a little while. But when the tension builds again, the violent process repeats. 

Some scholars have suggested that religious sacrifices are simply a way of managing this kind of rivalry in communities.  But actually, when we look more carefully, we see that Jewish and Christian scriptures consistently confront the horror of these violent patterns, critiquing themselves by telling the story of their rivalry as well as their scapegoats. Think of Cain and Abel, or Jacob and Esau, or Sarah and Hagar. Or Jonah.

So with that in mind, what do you think Jesus is doing with this parable about the vineyard, and the wicked tenants?  What do these wicked tenants want, and how might the story Jesus tells work to change what listeners want? 

This is the second in a series of parables, told to a very particular audience in Jerusalem, not long before Jesus is arrested. 

And he tells it in response to the questions they ask him. Their questions were, “Do you hear what they are saying?” and “By what authority do you do these things?” 

The crowd asking these questions included theologically progressive pharisees, theologically conservative temple officials, priests, scribes, and ordinary people, all of whom had just witnessed Jesus fulfill all the signs of David by turning over the tables in the Temple, healing people on the Temple mount, and teaching to the tune of crowds singing “Hosanna to the son of David.” 

So each of these groups from their own social locations and perspectives were asking Jesus, “do you hear what they are saying?  By what authority do you do these things?” 

 So as to let them decide for themselves, Jesus answered by telling them the parable of two sons, also known as the prodigal son. You know it. The son who stayed home had never wanted a fatted calf or a party until he saw his brother get one. The son who came home learned to want what he once had, and in returning, got even more than he asked for. And Jesus’s answer to their questions, tucked neatly into the story, was essentially this: Sons who do the will of their fathers carry the authority of their fathers. So if you see what I am doing as God’s will, accept that it is by God’s merciful authority that I do it. 

Then, Jesus told the parable of these tenants in the vineyard, and an owner who sends for his fruit. It was a way of turning the questions back on his listeners.  “What do you think the landowner will do to the tenants when he returns?” Jesus asks. And perhaps it is another way of asking “so, what do you want me to do for you?” 

Now in the Ancient Roman Empire, absentee landowners were quite common.  So it was also common for tenants, or caretakers of the land to work the land on behalf of the landowner.  Even in fruitful years, the tenants lived at subsistence level at best, and the fruit of their labor was sold for the sake of the landowner. And as you can imagine, this system perpetuated injustices….injustices with which the people of Israel were well-acquainted. After all, their land was occupied by Romans, claimed by absentee officials, who were represented by authorities like King Herod, or Pontius Pilate. An absentee landowner would not have been an immediate protagonist in anybody’s story, because people would have easily seen themselves in the tenants. 

But these were wicked tenants…so maybe that set some distance between them. And because God’s people had been likened to a vineyard throughout Hebrew texts, in this parable, the absentee landowner could have also been perceived as God, who was the rightful owner of this vineyard.  God brought a vine out of Egypt, planted and tended it for a season, and it flourished, but then God left it to the care of others. As a result, it was trampled by wild beasts and overgrown with weeds and wild things. So the people of Israel longed for God, the rightful landowner, to return to them, and vindicate them by driving out the wicked, and restoring their vineyard.

The Pharisees imagined that coming to pass in a particular way, and Temple officials in another, and scribes in yet another, and ordinary people longed for it, too, but in their own ways. And those distinctions produced rivalry, and mimetic desire among them. 

 So Jesus asks this conflicted crowd of people “what do you think the owner will do to the tenants when he returns?” 

But maybe what Jesus was really getting at was, “Who do you blame for the situation you are in? What do you want me to do for you?”

And maybe, when the crowd answered, they were thinking mostly of the ones they blamed and opposed most in the crowd alongside them, when they said “he will put them to a miserable death!” 

And there it was.  Mimetic desire. A scapegoat who deserved it. 

But Jesus, so aware of the ancient texts that critique this kind of rivalry, said or maybe he almost whispered, “Have you never read in the scriptures, the stone that the builders rejected has become the cornerstone, it is the Lord’s doing, and it is amazing in our eyes?”

To put anyone in the position of the tenants deserving of death in Jesus’s story was to judge oneself, too.  

The restoration they were longing for had come in the form of a man who was willing to be rejected for doing the will of his father.  A man whose desires would not be shaped or influenced by the envy and rivalry of others. A man who knew what he wanted: to do the will of his father for the sake of the whole world. Those who could bear the fruit of that truth were to become co-heirs in the vineyard of God. 

I imagine those first listeners were drawn in beyond their ability to escape by then, drawn into their own schemes to enthrone or kill this man as he said words they knew, words that were so familiar but in a context that was so different…. Jesus was doing the will of his father, and even if they killed him for it, God’s reign would prevail.  Jesus was going to identify as the scapegoat, and he seemed to be saying that this terrible scapegoating ritual that was about to be done to him was truly terrible, but that he was uniquely blessed beyond all the violence he would absorb, and he intended to share that blessing. 

It is because he shared that blessing, free from rivalry and fear, and abounding in mercy, that we encounter Christ here today. 

 I don’t know whose desire we are mimicking when we demand a scapegoat for all our injuries, rivalries, and envy. 

But I know that this question Jesus asks his listeners has the power to change the desires we mimic. To engage with Jesus is to stumble and fall and break open our true motives, and in the middle of it all, to begin mimicking God’s desires until blessedly, mercifully, they become our own. 

Almighty and everlasting God, you are always more ready to hear than we to pray, and to give more than we either desire or deserve: Pour upon us the abundance of your mercy, forgiving us those things of which our conscience is afraid, and giving us those good things for which we are not worthy to ask, except through the merits and mediation of Jesus Christ our Savior; who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, for ever and ever. Amen².

_________________________________________________

¹ I am indebted to Catholic theologian and former priest James Alison for explaining Renė Girard’s theory in relation to this parable at a gathering I attended.  He spoke about it at St. Leo’s Catholic Church in April of 2016.  You can find his sermons and talks on related subjects here.
² Collect for Proper 22, The Book of Common Prayer, p. 234

I'm just this kid from Worthington

Preached on the Feast of St. Michael and All Angels (transferred), September 27, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Stephen Crippen.

Genesis 28:10-17
Psalm 103:19-22
Revelation 12:7-12
John 1:43-51 (verses added to the appointed Gospel)

Jacob’s Ladder, by William Blake

“I’m just this kid from Worthington.” That’s something I like to say in text messages with a certain friend of mine, signaling real (if playful) modesty after I say something highfalutin or pompous. I’m not uppity. I don’t have a big ego. I’m just this kid from Worthington.

My friend was born in Jonesboro, Arkansas, and for a time lived in Rock Island, Illinois. He’s married to someone who grew up in Davenport, Iowa. I’m married to someone born in San Jose who lived in Tucson. I know very few native New Yorkers, and even fewer – nearly zero – native Parisians or Londoners or Tokyoites. 

Maybe you come from somewhere famous, a top-tier city. Or you hail from a blue-blood family line. Are you the scion of a dynastic clan? My father was interested in genealogy and discovered a thin but durable connection between our family and a passenger on the Mayflower in 1620. But that is now a dubious distinction, given what we’ve learned, all too recently, about the impact of English colonists on this continent.

I am not the son of a royal house. I am not a Windsor or a Kennedy or a Bush or a Kardashian or a Hilton. I did not attend an Ivy League school.

I’m just this kid from Worthington.

Worthington: a little town that grew up by a lake and a railroad crossing in remote southwestern Minnesota. I have no doubt none of you has ever been there. Many of you may have unwittingly flown over Worthington: it’s deep in ‘flyover country’. When they opened a Hardee’s fast-food joint in the early eighties, we kids rejoiced. These days it is known for an international windsurfing festival, held on the shores of Lake Okabena, where the waves are whipped high by prairie winds. But you have not heard of that festival. I’m almost sure of it.

Robert Kennedy (senior) visited Worthington in 1966. They say the crowds swelled to about 80,000 on that historic day. But in the six decades since, my hometown has not made national news.

Can anything good come out of Worthington?

Nazareth, in turn, has produced only one famous resident. Well, two. Okay, three: Jesus and his parents, Mary and Joseph. They are, of course, historically famous, their fame many orders of magnitude huger than that of the most media-savvy Kardashian. They have changed the western world. The eastern world, too: they have changed the whole world.

But there was a time when a kid from Cana in Galilee could look derisively on a kid from Nazareth. Did you grow up in Edmonds, Washington? If so, maybe you are a modern Nathanael, saying with derision, “She’s from Puyallup. Can anything good come out of Puyallup?”

This is the scandal, the absurdity, of the incarnation. Those who first heard the Christian Gospel were understandably perplexed, sometimes even outraged, by the idea that God, who created the universe and whose purposes for the universe will always far transcend the human imagination — that God comes among us as an ordinary human being from the next town down the road, an itinerant preacher and folk healer, an executed peasant prophet, a kid from Nazareth. God comes among us as a human person, just like you and me. How ridiculous!

There are human beings around most of you right now, to your right or to your left. (Some of you watching the livestream may be alone in your room.) Speaking of livestream, our livestream manager, trained in the world of audio and video technology, calls us human beings “bags of water.” (That’s our physical impact on the sound quality in this room, at least. We’re lumps who deaden the sound.) But that is actually what we are: bags of water, bundles of bones and nerves, tangles of guts and veins, with ingrown toenails and slimy ear wax. God became one of us? 

Yes, says the Christian. God comes to us as a bag of water, born in the hinterland, sitting next to us in the pew.

But… assuming for a moment that God can do this, why would God do this? Back to Nathanael, who snarks: “Can anything good come out of Nazareth?” This sharp question is a diplomatic (if arch) way to say that Jesus was a hick, a hillbilly. And Nathaneal would know. He was found under a fig tree, an image meant to evoke scholarship: working-class folk did not rest under fig trees during work hours. That takes the leisure of a scholar. Nathanael was probably what we’d call lettered: an educated man, probably erudite. He comes from Cana in Galilee, which is not an imperial capital, not a glittering urban paradise: no, Cana is hardly more distinctive than Nazareth, making Nathanael’s contempt for Jesus more than a little absurd. (He was probably projecting…) But Nathanael nevertheless is educated, world-wise, savvy. (Something good did come out of Cana.)

And so Nathanael is a decent stand-in for us, who mostly share his access to education, his worldliness. Nathanael is our way into today’s Good News. It’s our turn to ask: Can God come among us as a human, and if so, why would God appear as a hick from the hills, an unknown redneck, a dusty tradeworker? Why would God carry divinity all the way down to earth, all the way down to a basin of grimy water he uses to wash our feet?

Answer: The incarnation drops from the heights of heaven — from the realm of angels — all the way down to our dirty feet so that the whole world can be reconciled to God. The Good News finds its way into every bag of water. You may have humble beginnings and an unremarkable life history, but God comes to you. God is embodied in you. You are invited to be part of the incarnation, to be caught up in it, to be lifted ever higher, through the realm of angels, to abide with God, in Jesus. 

And: it’s always been this way, since the time of the first Christian communities. Let’s take a quick second to look at who they really were.

It’s easy to read the New Testament and imagine our first Christian forebears as sophisticated urbanites. The early Church flourished in grand (or at least grand-sounding) cities: Rome, Antioch, Alexandria, Constantinople, Jerusalem. But those cities were not at all huge by our standards. Tokyo would baffle them in its daunting immensity.

Cities like Philippi and Corinth were even smaller. They were dense little towns, their tight neighborhoods crammed with humans. Privacy was almost non-existent. The biblical scholar Wayne Meeks describes these compact little urban villages. He writes, “A peddler of copper pans or magic amulets, of horoscopes or a revelation, could count on the word [of his trade] getting around — once he had made his initial contacts.”

The Word of God was made manifest in the unremarkable alleys and lanes of towns that dotted the Mediterranean. And those little communities, following a kid from Nazareth, banded together and changed the whole known world. The Gospel made it to the tiniest town, the most far-flung village, the most overlooked railroad crossing in flyover country.

And so I encourage you to relax, to take a breath, as you sit and reflect on this morning’s Good News. God comes close to you, an ordinary human being who likely was born in unremarkable, ordinary circumstances. God comes close to you, a tax-paying voting citizen who’s worried whether you can afford retirement. God comes close to you, an undocumented partner in ministry who has to research how to get a visa, and what to do if that’s impossible, in a time when being found by our government without documentation could mean the end of your life. God comes close to you.

And just listen to what that kid from Nazareth says to Nathanael, a kid from Cana who is climbing a near-vertical learning curve as it dawns on him that this Nazarean is really, vitally, ultimately important. The kid from Nazareth says Nathanael “will see greater things” than the seemingly clairvoyant awareness Jesus had of Nathanael’s whereabouts and identity. “Very truly I tell you,” Jesus says, “You will see the heavens opened and the angels of God ascending and descending on the Son of Man.”

This cryptic statement foretells a few things. Jesus was likely referring to the first wondrous sign of his identity and mission that will happen at Nathanael’s own little Cana in Galilee, where Jesus will turn hundreds of gallons of water into fine wine, a dazzling sign of the abundance of grace that God brings to earth in the form of this ordinary kid from the sticks. But Jesus was also likely referring to his resurrection and ascension, when he himself will climb Jacob’s ladder back up to heaven, completing the incarnation.

The Word of God descends from cosmic glory into the earthy, workaday world of a backwater town in an unremarkable countryside, and further down still, finally kneeling in jaw-dropping humility at the dirty feet of his friends. Then he rises up, up, up to heaven, and he takes us with him. The incarnation — incarnation, a word that means in-flesh or enfleshed — is not only the descent of God into our messy human world. It is also the journey back up, and we get to come along.

The ingenious architects who designed this building wisely gave us a room that illustrates this parabolic path of incarnation. If you look to your left and right, you’ll notice a cozy intimacy: Even at 8:00am, when just a dozen or two people occupy this room, it doesn’t feel cavernous or empty. You can readily see the faces of your friends.

But then, look up. Gaze up at the skylights dozens of feet above you. See how the columns, like huge tree trunks, rise into the sky and turn this room into a great forest glade. God is immanent here, but God is also transcendent from here.

And so it is with you. Maybe you feel you have a little life, that you’re making a small, insignificant impact, that there isn’t much you can say or do about the roiling world so beset by injustice and atrocity. But then, look up. You may have been born in the middle of nowhere, but here, around this Table, you become a member of Christ’s Body, and there is no action of yours so tiny that it won’t make a surprising positive impact on this beloved world created by God.

You, a kid from an unremarkable town: You will do greater things than these.

The anti-hero we all need

Preached on the Seventeenth Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 20A), September 20, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Kelly Moody.

Jonah 3:10-4:11
Psalm 145:1-8
Philippians 1:21-30
Matthew 20:1-16

Willamette Vineyard, by Erin Hanson

Jonah doesn’t come across as the healthiest leader, does he?  I kept thinking as I read this text this week that I’m glad the prophet Jonah isn’t our rector.¹  

Jonah doesn’t even like the people to whom he is sent. He resists his call to preach repentance at every turn, drawing innocent sailors into the conflict, and then he pouts when God effects what God intends through his reluctant leadership. Throughout the story, God is repeatedly merciful, not only to Jonah, but to the sailors, and to the Ninevites.  But all we can really say about Jonah is that he is cranky. Not even cranky in a characteristically prophetic way, like Elijah, Jeremiah, or Amos or the other Hebrew prophets, who engage extreme language and performative actions to persuade their people to turn to God, but particularly cranky, in that Jonah’s objection is not with the people at all. It’s with God. 

God is not following the rules. The Ninevites are wicked and deserve punishment, and it’s God’s job to make that happen. And everyone knows that God does not change God’s mind. It says so in the Torah.² The prophet Samuel said so, too, when he confronted Saul about his wickedness and oversaw the selection of a new king.  But in this story, God’s mind is changed anyway. And aside from the theological problem this presents, it puts Jonah in an impossible situation, calling him to declare that doom will come upon the Ninevites, his enemies…only for God to relent, making Jonah look like a liar and a fool. 

But Jonah is especially upset because he knew God would change God’s mind and wouldn’t follow the rules.  He knew because he was aware that above all, God is gracious and full of compassion, slow to anger and abounding in kindness and faithfulness to the thousandth generation.³ God said so to Moses at the giving of the law, and Moses remembered it again when they were wandering in the wilderness and the next generation of people were complaining.⁴ Jonah knew because he knew the psalms of David,⁵ like Psalm 86, and 103, and 145, which we sang this morning, all of which repeat the same truth about God: The Lord is compassionate and gracious, slow to anger, and abounding in steadfast love. 

This attribute of God perplexes Jonah. He wants a God who is consistent, and follows the rules.  A God who exerts power and gets things done, and doesn’t show mercy to those who don’t deserve it, especially Assyrians in Nineveh. And yet it’s by God’s mercy that Jonah survives a storm, and a whale, and scorching heat. 

Now it’s unlikely that Jonah was a real person, but I think that makes his story all the more interesting.  Why would a scribe write the story of Jonah reluctantly preaching repentance to his enemies and complaining about it, if not to express something important about God, and about humanity?

After all, this merciful attribute of God often perplexes us, too. We want God to be fair, consistent, and on our side, not theirs. We want God’s mercy, but not for everyone.  For those who have bested us or wounded us, we might prefer God’s retribution instead.

Many Christians have concluded that God is retributive and transactional in the Old Testament, while Jesus the merciful, rule-breaking one who preaches love and anti-establishment religion.  And yet, that clearly isn’t the whole story, is it? Just ask Jonah. 

At sunset tonight, Yom Kippur, the Jewish day of Atonement begins, and tomorrow afternoon, the book of the prophet Jonah will be read in its entirety. Those present will likely be encouraged to identify not with wayward Jonah, but with the Ninevites, whose repentance demonstrates integrity and amendment of life in response to a God who is gracious and merciful and full of compassion. Ironically, the Ninevites model the behavior people of God should emulate, not Jonah. 

And yet, there is a Jonah that persists in all of us.  A Jonah who needs to make it about him. A Jonah who doesn’t want people he doesn’t like to receive God’s mercy. A Jonah who might prefer a transactional yet fair God who gets things done to a God who exercises compassion.

Jonah is not a fool we can just ignore or marginalize. He’s like the anti-hero of the Hebrew prophets, and his career as a prophet becomes even more pronounced and effective through his literary impact on us all these years later. Because when we really explore Jonah’s theological complaint with God, we begin to see our own. God is not fair, not  limited to who we thought God was… not confined by the rules we thought we wanted God to follow, or the conception of God we liked best. God is gracious and compassionate, even when we wish God would smite the wicked instead. The God of the Old Testament is also the God of the New Testament, revealed to us in Jesus, and to be in relationship with this God is to be humbled over and over again, like Jonah, as we wrestle with our own theological complaints, and surrender to God’s mercy.

Historically, Christians have projected their theological complaints about God on others instead of claiming them, and wrestling with them honestly. It can sound something like this: “The God of the Old Testament was exacting and angry and picked favorites, but Jesus preached love and forgiveness and welcomed everyone.” Or this: “The Jews believed that following the law was the most important thing, but we know that God cares about mercy and justice.” Or even this: At the time, the religious system of the temple was transactional and legalistic, but Jesus came to change that…” 

And ironically, it is not the Ninevites that help us Christians find a different way to tell the story of our salvation, but Jonah. By his theological protest, Jonah calls out our anti-Jewish projections, and invites us into a more honest story about our relationship with God that doesn’t rely on scapegoats.  One that requires us to grapple with our complaints about when and how and to whom God shows mercy instead of projecting them on others. 

As Christians, we believe we are invited into the unfolding story of God’s mercy and grace through our identification with Jesus, who we believe is God. And on this solemn day of Jewish atonement, a Sunday in which we Christians celebrate the resurrection of Jesus, I think it’s worth remembering that God’s favor toward us came by way of one who belonged to a different group of people, with their own story about God.  Their engagement with the God of mercy began long before ours. It’s distinct from ours, just as Nineveh’s story was distinct from Jonah’s, and it isn’t finished yet. 

Jews and Christians share many stories, like this one about Jonah. But we are also fundamentally different, and our texts invite us to see that God is generous across differences in ways that can offend us. So maybe, as the antihero-prophet does his work on us, we Christians can grapple with our offenses more honestly, and learn to tell the stories of God’s mercy without making another group of people the foil in the plot.  Maybe we can allow these stories to destabilize our assumptions, and draw us out of ourselves and our temptation to make it all about us. Maybe we can meet God in Jesus, and step more fully into the unfolding story of God’s abundant mercy.

Jonah may not have been the healthiest leader.  But he turns out to be an excellent and effective prophet in spite of everything, even to us, all these years later. I’m still glad he’s not our rector, but I’m also really thankful that our rector has an image of Jonah tattooed on his arm. Because a little bit of Jonah persists in all of us, and the good news is that there is a God who persists, too. A God whose persistent orientation is toward mercy and grace. A God who will not end the story with our theological complaints and offenses, but will instead keep calling us into a bigger story of redemption and grace. 

_________________________________________________

¹ Thanks to The Christian Century for this inspiration: https://www.christiancentury.org/voices/terrible-leaders-bible
² Numbers 23:19, as noted in JPS’s Jewish Study Bible.
³ Exodus 34:6-7
⁴ Numbers 14:18
⁵ Psalm 86:15, 103:8-11, 145:8

You just have to understand this!!

Preached on the Sixteenth Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 19A), September 13, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Stephen Crippen.

Genesis 50:15-21
Psalm 103:8-13
Romans 14:1-12
Matthew 18:21-35

Painting detail depicting coins in the Ca’Doro palace in Venice

“Bless us with anger,” Bishop Gene Robinson prayed, on Sunday, January 18, 2009, in Washington, D.C. The setting was a “kick-off” concert celebrating the inauguration, two days later, of a new president. 

“Bless us with anger.”

The bishop asked God for the blessing of anger in response to discrimination against “refugees and immigrants, women, people of color, gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender people.” When we witness this discrimination, may God bless us with anger.

But how can anger be a blessing? Anger so often is destructive. Anger motivates acts of violence. Anger in even small amounts can be corrosive. Someone cuts you off in traffic and you flip them the bird: This is corrosive. It damages, however slightly, our social fabric.

Often enough I feel angry. Often enough I understand the function and value, if not the “blessing,” of anger: we humans evolved this sharp emotion. Anger urges us to fight, to make ourselves bigger, to assert, to overcome. Anger has been described simply as the feeling you have when something is in your way. There’s a barrier in front of you, and anger helps you remove that barrier.

But anger, in the quarter century since 9/11, is running rampant. Anger is now chronic. Anger seizes our social media, driving us all wild with resentment and frustration. We seethe with anger at our enemies, at many, even most, of our political authorities.

This seems to be an era of forever wars, of forever anger: there is no end in sight for the unjust and ridiculous war in Ukraine. There is no end in sight for the atrocious violence committed by Israeli settlers in the West Bank, armed with weapons purchased with funds from the United States. There is no end in sight for the chaos and appalling violence of the endless civil war in Sudan, a war nearly everyone else in the world ignores. 

There is no end in sight for the churning anger and rage of our polarized political world, where every news cycle offers an answer to this wretched question: who can behave the most reprehensibly? There is a political candidate here, and another there, who rises above the vitriol and runs an ethical, honest campaign. I have donated to one of these candidates, and I hope he wins. But our nation furiously rages against itself, and the wins are few.

How can anger be a blessing?

Let’s begin with the anger Bishop Robinson prayed that we would feel: anger on behalf of survivors of discrimination. That anger is a blessing when it leads to effective action, to powerful allegiance, to the presence of justice. When injustice is in our way, anger shoves it aside.

But we hear about a more straightforward, personal anger in today’s Good News. Of course, anger on behalf of survivors of discrimination can certainly be personal: maybe you’re mad about our culture’s rejection and abuse of trans persons because you yourself are nonbinary, or your spouse is trans, or your child is genderqueer. But the anger in the troubling parable of Jesus is personal in a communal sense: it is the anger of a whole community of faith, outraged that their values were crossed by one of their own members.

This anger is not sparked by outside agents acting badly, by an online culture-war bigot, or an unnamed masked ICE agent. The community is angry because one of their own has misbehaved. He received mercy, but then he turned around and denied that same mercy to his companion. That crossed a line. That was a terrible thing to do.

Of course the characters in the parable are not whole communities, but individuals, so it could hit us as a moral tale about one-to-one injustice, one-to-one anger: there’s a king, and he has some slaves. But the first hearers of this parable were a first-century Christian community, maybe a network of house churches, and the lesson is about all of them, about the values they all share, about the power those values hold over all of their imaginations, about how dead-serious Jesus is that all of them, all of us, should be acting on our deepest beliefs, our deepest convictions.

We must not deny others the mercy we ourselves have received! We must not!

To get this point across, Jesus gets vivid. He gets provocative. He turns up the heat. He already had us squirming with the bit about a king and his slaves: that economic system rightly repels us. It’s worse than even our own unjust capitalist economy. The first listeners of his words were doubtless not wild about kings and slavery, either. They lived in an occupied land. They knew in their bones how powerless and vulnerable most people were in their day.

But Jesus goes further. The king calls the unforgiving slave “wicked” — an extreme take on his character. And even worse, the king hands the slave over to be tortured until he repays his debt, a debt which originally had been forgiven. 

And even worse than that, Jesus wraps up his rant by saying, “So my heavenly Father will also do to every one of you, if you do not forgive your brother or sister from your heart.” The Father will torture us if we don’t forgive as we have been forgiven! It’s all so extreme, so wildly over the top.

That is how important this teaching is: Matthew’s Gospel has Jesus raging, here. It’s as if the evangelist is pleading with us, “Please, please, you just have to understand this!!”

The king extends mercy to his slave, who is drowning in debt. But hold up: please note that debt here is not just a metaphor: we could read this whole parable as a homily on economic justice and fully understand its true meaning. We are a Christian community, and are taught in general to forgive and be merciful, but that forgiveness and mercy is chiefly about economic justice.

Our values are not just about being kind and gentle neighbors, about doing to others as we want them to do to us, about living life with gratitude and hospitality, about spiritual transformation and warm community celebrations. We do proclaim those values! But closer to the quick, for us, most essential for us, as followers of Jesus, is this: God creates a splendid world that should be bountiful and nourishing for everyone, not just the few. Every human person should rest under a roof, and eat at a dinner table, and learn at a nearby school, and find gainful work that draws on their gifts and skills. Economic justice is the beating heart of Christian ethics.

And so we are taught to be enraged when that value is crossed. We are angry not just to feel a proud sense of righteous outrage, but to then shove that injustice out of the way, so that all are fed, and sheltered, and educated, and employed.

We rightly concern ourselves with welcoming everyone who comes in these doors, for we follow the one who ate with disreputable people and empowered women and other survivors of economic injustice to his abundant table. But we pray for the blessing of anger to go deeper, to work ever harder, to do whatever we can, always with God’s power, to mend this damaged world, so torn asunder by inequality, greed, and selfishness. 

In a few moments we will confess together our sins — the sins for which we share mutual responsibility, common culpability — and then we will embrace in the Lord’s peace. We do not have an anger ritual in our Sunday mass! Be reassured: the lesson today is not that we should rage against one another. No, it’s not that at all.

It is this: Nourished by this abundant Table that groans under the weight of God’s grace, our bellies full and spirits forgiven, we are to rise up in common purpose, and yes, if necessary, in righteous anger, to “forgive our brother or sister from our heart,” that is, to forgive their debts: to shatter the economic vise that presses so mercilessly on our companions, on our neighbors, on our fellow citizens, on children and families in Gaza and Sudan, in Ukraine and Cuba, in south King County, in Uptown, in this room, in your pew.

So yes, Lord, yes — you who trampled death by death, you who ate with outcasts and raged against the forces of oppression — yes: bless us today. Bless us to rise up and right the wrongs of this world. Bless us to thunder out of here on your mission of mercy.

Bless us with anger.

How do we become better, more loving people?

Preached on the Fifteenth Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 18A), September 6, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Kelly Moody.

Forgiveness, by Sofiya Inger

How do we become better, more loving people?

Maybe a more churchy way of asking this question is this: how does conversion of life happen? What do we imagine is happening when we say the confession each week, for example?  

I ask because in spite of the beautiful words of our liturgies and prayers, I think we in the church have often struggled to imagine what these prayerfully chosen words actually mean in our everyday lives. 

We suffer from a lack of imagination. 

So take just a moment and try to imagine what repentance looks like in your life… or forgiveness… or conversion. 

What comes to mind? 

Some of us might think of global conflicts that demand our best efforts at peace, or unjust systems we must fight to dismantle.  Certainly, a willingness to persist in these ways is an important aspect of a hearty theological imagination. I think of people like Desmond Tutu, who could imagine a world without apartheid, and worked to make it a reality.  Others might think of ruptures in particular relationships, or personal failings or blind spots that have led to conflicts, and the necessary work of reconciliation and amendment of life. Perhaps the most well-loved depiction of that kind of conversion is Ebenezer Scrooge in Charles Dickens’ Christmas Carol; and his  imaginative journey through past, present and future.  

But where is God at work in all of this? How do we imagine that God is involved in our conversion toward better, more loving people?

By the time the prophet Ezekiel was serving as a sentinel for the house of Israel, where God was in all of this was a central question for the exiled people to which he was sent.  The first temple in Jerusalem had been destroyed.  The people  had acknowledged their collective waywardness, and attempted to turn back to the Lord, but they were still suffering the effects of exile, still longing for the legitimacy of a kingdom.  All they could imagine was what they had lost. When would restoration come?  What would it take to change course? 

Despite the many historical and cultural differences between Ezekiel’s time and ours, I don’t think these questions are unfamiliar to us in our own cultural context.  We, too,  lament the waywardness and failure of our political leaders. We, too,  consider what it will take to collectively change course on the climate crisis, for example. We regularly seek God in prayer, and in various ways we ask, “where are you in all of this? What will it take for change to happen? How do we become better, more loving people?”

Now the Bible includes a few different ideas about how humans can change. There’s the conditional, behavior-oriented language of the commandments in Exodus or Deuteronomy: If you do this, then you will live. If you don’t, then you will die.   Then, there’s the somatic language of wisdom literature, like the Psalm from this morning: Incline my heart, turn my eyes, make my feet go in the path of righteousness. Texts like this seem to concede that following God’s commandments requires some divine assistance to get us to do what is required. In the text from Ezekiel today, humans amend their lives by following the advice of God’s chosen prophet. Ezekiel just has to tell the people the words he hears from God, and then the people can choose to turn from their wickedness based on his intervention.  

But in other parts of Ezekiel and Jeremiah, people become better by God’s direct initiative- he will inscribe his law on their hearts¹, create in them a clean heart², give them a new spirit³, like a divine surgeon.   

So there’s a variety of ideas, but in each of them, there is a creative tension that must be held.  We human beings are simultaneously rough around the edges, and radically transformed by our relationship with God. Living into the tension between the two requires a robust theological imagination that can hold both truths at the same time. 

Biblical scholars call this mysterious tension dual agency, or co-agency: a cooperative blend of human and divine action⁴ that enables us to act according to God’s desires.  Christian theology calls it grace. 

Both challenge our modern understanding of the self,  and our western cultural value in acting self-sufficiently to accomplish whatever goals we set our minds to.  Both involve engagement with God

“Self-help is America’s religion,” historian Kate Bowler says.⁵  There is a religious fervor to the self-optimization that pervades our culture. Ourselves, our communities…everything around us becomes a project that can be improved upon if we just lock in, and work a little harder. This is a kind of theological imagination, but it’s a thin one; a transactional, mechanistic understanding of ourselves and others that flattens our humanity into machine-like simplicity, and reduces our capacity to be present to those around us in love, just as they are.    

In contrast, Jesus says to his disciples, “Where two or three are gathered in my name, I am there among them.” It is not conditional, or individual. It is communal.He inspires them to imagine themselves in communion, even when they are apart, because they are, and to work together even when they are opposed, because they are yoked together. He echoes the same idea from the Hebrew Bible that God acts in cooperation with human efforts to forgive, restore, and strengthen us. And so, with God’s help, maybe we can imagine becoming people who can tolerate the rough and unfinished edges of others, but can also tell them the truth about those edges. With God’s help, maybe we can imagine becoming people who delight in the sheer gift of grace, and simultaneously lean into the longing for a restoration that is beyond reach in this life. With God’s help, maybe we can imagine becoming loving people who can hold the tension between the two truths that we are both rough around the edges and radically transformed at the same time. It’s in this mysterious sacramental tension between human life and divine life that grace enters in and transforms us. 

I am a native Tennessean, whose ancestors hail from Southern milltowns and Appalachian hollers, and after Dolly Parton died last week, I watched with appreciation and awe as the tributes to her memory poured in from every corner of our divided country.  Her rags-to-riches trajectory could easily be mistaken for a classic American tale of individual self-actualization, and at least a few journalists have depicted it that way. 

But Dolly Parton told a different story about herself- a story that inspired people, whether they were making it big or down on their luck, because it held the tension between the rough edges of her upbringing and her radical rise to fame. She claimed them both. Maybe one of the most captivating things about her was her ability to gently engage with nationally divisive topics, leaving imaginative room for people from opposing camps to enter into dialogue with her. When she sang about sexism in the music business, people who might never have given a feminist the time of day listened. When she wrote songs for Transamerica and Love Rocks, people who did not understand the queer community listened. When she rewrote her musical show, Dixie Stampede, to avoid glorification of the antebellum south,  people paid attention. 

One journalist said it like this:  “In her life, as in so many of her songs, Parton celebrated understanding and forgiveness as a means of transcending rancour and shame.⁶” 

I read that line and I thought, “what would it be like if the church was as well-known for celebrating understanding and forgiveness as Dolly Parton was?  It’s in all of our songs and liturgies, after all. 

What if we could hold the tension as well as she did between the rough edges of humanity and the radical transformation we believe is possible in Christ?  

What if we could claim them both, welcome them both? 

Can you imagine it? 

_________________________________________________

¹ Jeremiah 31
² Psalm 51
³ Ezekiel 36
⁴ For more insight about self, agency and the spirit, check out Carol Newsom’s The Spirit Within Me and Reed Carlson’s Unfamiliar Selves.
⁵ Consider Bowler’s thought-provoking work as presented in this brief video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c3tZR1ZY1N8
⁶ Read the full article here: https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20201204-how-dolly-parton-became-the-worlds-best-loved-celebrity

Why aren't we talking about fascism?!

Preached on the Fourteenth Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 17A), August 30, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Stephen Crippen.

Jeremiah 15:15-21
Psalm 26:1-8
Romans 12:9-21
Matthew 16:21-28

Take Up Your Cross, mixed media collage by John Kohan

“Why aren’t we talking about fascism?”

That’s what someone was asking, over the past few days. I was working near Columbus, Ohio, as one of the trainers for the College for Congregational Development in the Diocese of Southern Ohio.

We covered lots of topics: congregational identity, Episcopal identity, how to map the neighborhood around your church to discern where God is sending you next on your mission, how to look at your congregation through different lenses to see different things — things like where you are on the organizational life cycle. If you’re wondering, St. Paul’s Seattle is currently in the “healthy stability” stage of our organizational life.

We learned a tool to discover who is coming to our congregations to develop their faith, and how best to nurture and lead them; and another tool to discern how the faithful enter their worlds of family, work, neighborhood, and civic life, and what (if anything) they do in those worlds that’s different or better because they said their prayers with us.

“Why aren’t we talking about fascism?” the participant said again. He mentioned this concern in his small group, in our main plenary sessions, and in his written evaluation of the week, which he filled out at the end of our time together. He seemed frustrated because, he reasoned, if we aren’t talking about the crisis of fascism currently threatening not just livelihoods but lives in our nation, a crisis trapping and killing people along the Strait of Hormuz, along our southern border, inside our urban centers and neighborhoods, just outside these doors, everywhere – if we aren’t talking about this global calamity, then, this participant said, we are blessing the status quo. We are going along with all the outrageous things that are happening. We are part of the problem.

He may as well have listened to all of our presentations about congregational development and all things church, and then said, “Get behind me, Satan! You are a stumbling block to me; for you are setting your mind not on divine things but on human things.”

I stand by everything we said and taught last week, but I have to concede: this might be a fair hit. Our materials address real and serious problems, problems that persist in 2026, but when a resource is just five years old (and some of ours are ten or more years old), it already feels outdated and insufficient. It’s not enough to lament all that’s going on. It’s not enough to read the headlines and volunteer and vote. Something more seems to be required. It feels insufficient for all of us to move through life, day by day, while these crises explode around us, relentlessly, for more than a decade now.

Yesterday I baked cake for coffee hour, a preoccupation that consumed much of my afternoon. Why wasn’t I talking about fascism?

You may have planned this afternoon to include quiet recreation, maybe some reading, maybe a nap. I’m sure you need the rest, but why aren’t you talking about fascism?

This is a good and just question to ask of ourselves. And yet, it is also more than a little annoying. Matthew the evangelist doesn’t tell us how Peter responds, internally or verbally, to the rebuke Jesus shouts at him. But I imagine he felt startled, confused, maybe ashamed… and maybe also annoyed.

They were in Caesarea Philippi, an important city named after a powerful tetrarch, a worship shrine for the god Pan and other deities, a city by a natural spring that feeds a tributary to the Jordan River. Gushing water flows out of a cave, and people in the time of Jesus imagined that the watery cave was an entrance to the underworld — a “gate of Hades.”

It was there, at that “gate of Hades,” where pilgrims revered powerful men and powerful gods and powerful spiritual forces — it was there that Peter had said that Jesus was the Messiah, the Anointed One, the One who rises above all other human and spiritual authorities. And it was there that Jesus had told Peter that he would be the rock on which Jesus would build his church, a rock against which the gate of Hades could never prevail. 

How iconic, how beautiful, how evocative of power and purpose, was this place; and how powerful these happy praises, given by Jesus to his best lieutenant!

It’s likely that Peter had been giddy with personal satisfaction and pride: he got the answer right! He named Jesus for who Jesus truly is. And now Peter is the Rock, the foundation. 

Imagine, then, Peter’s shock, his dismay, even his outrage when just a moment later Jesus turns on him and says “Get behind me, Satan!” Imagine your own dismay if you came to church so that you can get quiet, open the holy book, pray for the world, receive the sacrament of Holy Communion, and go back to your life of work and family, but here at church you encounter me, or my friend in southern Ohio, or some other scold, tapping your shoulder and snapping, “Why aren’t you talking about fascism?”

I do not think you would thank anyone for yelling that at you. I think you might feel annoyed, irritated, affronted, defensive, exasperated. I confess I didn’t feel persuaded or galvanized by this person’s accusation last week. I didn’t enthusiastically nod in agreement, saying, “Oh, you’re right, we should be talking about harder things, more urgent things! You’re so right!” I just inclined my head. I muttered something noncommittal like, “Yes, mmhm.” And now he and I are back in our different worlds, and he has no idea whether his objection had any effect on anyone.

But it did. It does. Here I am sharing it with you, even running the risk that I will annoy you by pressing us all with his valid concern. We are not free to only come to church, and say our prayers, and sing our hymns, and break bread together, and delight in baked goods and fresh coffee, and go back to our lives, with nothing changed.

More is expected of us.

Jesus makes this plain. “If any want to become my followers,” he says (and I can hear the exasperation in his voice: in my reading of the passage, he is still scolding Peter) – “If any want to become my followers, let them deny themselves and take up their cross and follow me. For those who want to save their life will lose it, and those who lose their life for my sake will find it. For what will it profit them if they gain the whole world but forfeit their life?”

We aren’t to come to church and bask in glory, marvel at the majesty of God, and call it good. We must “deny ourselves,” and “take up our cross,” and “follow Jesus.” Follow him where? Well, to his cross, of course: that is where he is headed.

Jesus does not stay north of the Galilee at this natural spring, at this shining monument to divine and human authority. He doesn’t linger there, musing on his own identity as the one who supersedes the human and spiritual authorities worshipped there. No, gets up and goes to Jerusalem, that tinderbox of political upheaval and intrigue, that dangerous city that kills the prophets, that imperial fortress that squelches dissent. Jesus walks right into danger, knowing full well what will happen.

After all, that’s why Peter got in trouble: he balked when Jesus said plainly what was about to happen: He will undergo great suffering, and be killed. “God forbid it, Lord!” Peter blurted. “This must never happen to you!”

But that’s not the way of Jesus. That’s not what church is. We are not a spa, a retreat center, an escape. We do give shelter, literal and spiritual, to everyone who comes here, and to nearby neighbors. We do make marvelous music and swim in soul-restoring silence. But there’s always more. The cross looms. We need to talk about fascism, yes. And we need to confront it. Organize against it. Protest and fight it. Stand firmly alongside its victims. Take up our cross.

But hear this Good News: We do this together, and we are fed and strengthened together, for the struggle. Nobody goes it alone, or does all the work. This Table is laden with food that feeds our deepest spiritual hungers. But that food is also energy for the struggle, electrolytes for the race, protein to help us lift the cross.

I am not sorry I spent an afternoon baking sweets for the sweet; and if you receive the blessing of a nap later today, I commend your good fortune. You need it, of this I’m sure. And I am not sorry our College for Congregational Development kept to its curriculum so that we can support good faith leaders in good congregations. Our life with Christ is not all duty, all drudgery, all battle and no shore leave.

But we do need to talk about fascism, and work against it. We do need to go to Jerusalem, wherever Jerusalem might be in our own time and place: the Jerusalem of our neighborhood mission, the Jerusalem of our advocacy against government oppression, the Jerusalem of our daily resistance to the forces that destroy human freedom and take human lives, the Jerusalem of lifting up members of this faith community in prayer and pastoral care.

For all of this good and hard work, this Table beckons. Come and receive, come and feed. Get nourished. Get ready. Pack whatever provisions you need for the journey. Soon we must be on our way.

The relationship is secure

Preached on the Thirteenth Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 16A), August 23, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Kelly Moody.

Byzantine style mosaic of Christ

Last summer, I had the opportunity to see “the David.”  You know, the famous marble statue in Florence, carved by Michelangelo?  He depicts David just before his battle with Goliath, tense, and turning to aim his slingshot.  It’s a massive work of art, considered a renaissance masterpiece. Michelangelo’s famed precision and attention to detail was clearly apparent as I observed the statue from the gallery floor. But what I didn’t know was that the carrera marble block out of which Michelangelo carved the David was rejected by two other sculptors. The block was darkly veined, and riddled with small holes.  And it was too narrow to accommodate the sort of figure that most sculptors envisioned. These imperfections forced Michelangelo to consider a different approach than he might have otherwise, and that unusual approach is part of what makes Michelangelo’s David such a masterpiece. No other sculptor was able to make anything of it.  In fact, David’s back is missing a muscle because of a previous sculptor’s unsuccessful attempt to carve the stone. Michelangelo’s work has been celebrated for centuries, and it was possible, in part, because he was willing to embrace what others thought was ruined, and work with the imperfections in this difficult piece of stone. 

“On this rock I will build my church,” Jesus says to Peter, who is not known to be the most solid of the disciples.  Scholars have debated what Jesus is referring to when he says “this rock.” Is it Peter, or Peter’s faith in Jesus, or, perhaps the rock is Jesus himself? 

The text is ambiguous.

 In any case, Peter’s recognition that Jesus is the son of the Living God is apparently a foundation strong enough for Jesus to work with, in spite of any imperfections or ambiguities. Their relationship is secure. 

That is not to say that Peter’s understanding of Jesus will not waver when faced with suffering and fear, because it will.  It’s not to say that Peter will not be disappointed when Jesus does not do what Peter expects a messiah to do, because he will be.  Peter struggles to recognize Jesus and what he is doing as often as he succeeds.  But Jesus is willing to embrace it all, and work with the imperfections.

The word Jesus uses to describe what he is building on this rock is translated here as church, but it can also be translated as assembly, or congregation.  So, another way of hearing this verse might be, “upon this relationship, where we recognize one another and work with the imperfections,  I will gather my people, my congregation, into a secure relationship.”  

We get a snapshot of Peter’s relationship with Jesus today in the gospel of Matthew, but what I find more compelling for those of us seeking to follow Jesus all these years later is Paul’s relationship with Jesus, and his recognition of Christ in the gathered body of the faithful in his letter to the Romans.

 After all,  Paul did not know Jesus before he was crucified.  He came to know him after his death, in visions, and dreams, and the goodwill of other Christ followers.  And in this letter to the Romans, Paul is writing to people who he likely never met, either… and identifying with Christ in them.  Because all of them– Peter, Paul, these Romans– all of them are captivated by their belief that this Galilean teacher named Jesus was trustworthy, and was still present, and could be known. They were willing to risk persecution and rejection to meet him. And it’s gatherings of the early church, like this one in Rome, receiving Paul’s letter, that have passed down the words and practices of our faith that we still rely on today:  Baptism. The pattern of our Eucharistic prayers. The laying on of hands. The collecting of scripture, like the phrase we heard today: we who are many are one body in Christ. 

Upon this multi-generational relationship, Christ still gathers his congregation, and is made known to us, too. 

Now throughout the course of history, many have given up on meeting Jesus in the church, because the church has failed to speak up at times… failed to bind worldly powers and loose the chains of injustice. Sometimes the church can appear to be an affinity group a or social club.  Other times, it just fails to articulate the most important thing. 

My friend was visiting a church for the first time, and upon attempting to dip her bread in the communion wine at the altar rail, the minister holding the chalice pulled it back and said rather sharply, “We don’t do that here.”  

It was an impulse, with no intention of harm, but the outcome was startling. My friend’s eyes filled with tears.  She returned to her seat, smarting from the interaction.  At first, she felt shame and rejection. Then she felt anger.  She hadn’t done anything wrong!  How was she supposed to know what they did or didn’t do if it wasn’t explicitly stated?  Then came rage.  Surely this is not how Jesus would treat an outsider who was seeking him.  

I hope you have not had an experience like this, not here or anywhere, but if you have, I am sorry.  It’s worth lamenting when the church misses the mark and falls short of its calling.  And it's important that we, the church, continue to repent when we fail. 

Because Jesus still gathers his people and is made known among us.  He still reveals himself in the words of scripture, read in a community of people earnestly seeking to follow him. Jesus still seeks out those who are looking for him, be they solid disciples or somewhat unreliable characters.  He still reveals himself in bread and wine. Jesus still calls and empowers people in every generation to join him in loving the world, and loosening the chains that restrict our lives. 

And this is the rock-solid foundation for our hope and persistence; that Jesus promised to gather and bless and empower all who come to him, and seek to know him. He was willing to take what others rejected, and work with the imperfections. 

So if you find yourself distracted today by imperfections, doubts and failures, be they yours or someone else’s, take heart. There’s more to the story.  The church is a place where we learn to recognize Christ in one another, and trust that the relationship is secure.  

"Bless us with anger..."

Preached on the (transferred) Feast of Saint Mary the Virgin, Mother of our Lord Jesus Christ, August 16, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington.

Isaiah 61:10-11
Psalm 34:1-9
Galatians 4:4-7
Luke 1:46-55

Icon by George Makary

Surely, from now on all generations will call me blessed; for the Mighty One has done great things for me, and holy is his name.

Our parents bless us. That is to say, our parents hand things down to us. Some of their gifts are conscious: they deliberately try to raise us a certain way, to instill certain values. They teach us how to treat our friends. They teach us what’s important, and what’s not. They teach us who is kin and who is an outsider. Sometimes they teach us how to vote, how to think, how to behave at dinner, even how to feel.

Other things parents give us are unintentional, unconscious… and they’re not all blessings. Sometimes parents let their children down in ways that give them deep-seated anxiety, and make it hard for their children to form strong emotional bonds with people. My parents formed secure emotional attachments with me, but I think they unintentionally taught me to suppress emotions, midwestern-style. I had to learn from somebody else that big feelings are useful, and good; that if I learn to work with them, they help me make better choices about my life.

Today we celebrate — we call “blessed,” we bless — a human being who is many things, as all of us are, but whose identity as a parent perhaps looms largest in our imagination. Saint Mary the Virgin has many titles, but perhaps her chief title, her primary claim to fame, is Mary the mother of Jesus, or Mary the mother of our Lord, or (we Christians came up with this title a bit later on) Mary the Mother of God.

Mary’s identity as a parent concerns us deeply. And as the mother of Jesus, she blesses him with many things. She also hands down to him, as all parents do (even absent or problematic parents) her worldview, her history, her legacy. 

She has the most to do and to say in the Good News according to Luke, where she gets to sing the mighty Magnificat, a triumphant song of praise that echoes her Hebrew forebear Hannah. (Hannah is yet another mother who blesses her child Samuel with powerful and provocative blessings!)

But back to Mary, and Mary in Luke’s Gospel: Mary’s Magnificat is an aria, not a recitative: She takes all the time she needs to sing God’s praises for bringing about the triumph of justice and peace through her, by her inconvenient and potentially scandalous pregnancy, with her own physical body.

We’ve never met Mary as Jesus did: obviously, whatever relationship we may have with Mary the Mother of God, the Queen of Saints, none of us knew her in first-century Nazareth. It is difficult to find the historical Mary behind ages of Marian devotion.

Mary captured the medieval imagination across several centuries, so much so that an ordinary Christian could mistake her for the Holy Spirit, given how powerfully she reigns as a source of consolation, comfort, and inspiration; as the majestic Lady Wisdom; as the divine feminine who pervades the created world with fecundity and beauty.

Mary is often, for us, a Madonna sparkling in a robe of stars, the Queen of Saints, iconic and beautiful, rising above our mundane world in sublime serenity. Think Queen Elizabeth the First, the virgin queen who said she was “married to England” and ruled her people wearing splendid gowns of fine silk, velvet, silver, and pearl. Her noble face was inscrutable, majestic, fierce, and her elaborate white makeup covered all human blemishes.

But Mary of Nazareth, the mother of Jesus, most likely looked nothing like that, and had a much more earthy character. She was a brown woman, probably quite short of stature, a survivor in a patriarchal world that routinely ignored or mistreated her. Physically she probably looked more like AOC than Elizabeth the First.

Now, I share the love many of you feel for Mary the Queen of Saints. Marian devotion is part of who we are in this Anglo-Catholic parish. When we revere Saint Mary; when we find her standing triumphantly on the moon; when we contemplate the astonishing mystery of the incarnation in which Mary’s womb contained “heaven and earth in little space” — all of this Marian piety powerfully deepens our understanding of God and humanity, both. We can begin to grasp how we, too, are ordinary human beings who nonetheless shine with God’s glory.

But it is also helpful to reflect on the historical Mary of Nazareth, a human being, born of a human being, who gave birth to a human being. Her son was divine and human. Mary of Nazareth has gifts for us. She inspires good questions for us to consider: What did Mary give to her son? How did she bless him? How did his life, ministry, death, and resurrection reflect her influence?

I have some ideas about all of that.

Mary gave her son the trauma she suffered in her very body as a peasant-class young woman in an occupied land. Just in the last decade or two, we have learned that trauma is not just an emotional (let alone a merely intellectual) experience, or memory. Trauma is experienced by, and remembered by, our bodies. The author Resmaa Menakem, in his book, My Grandmother’s Hands, studies the trauma of slavery and white-body supremacy suffered by black and brown bodies, and transmitted by those bodies to their children, and their children’s children.

But Menakem goes back even further in time, prior to the arrival of African people on this continent in 1619, and traces the trauma suffered by white bodies, inflicted by other white bodies, in medieval Europe and then in colonial America. Only generational trauma, held and transmitted in physical bodies, can explain both the invention of whiteness itself — for race is nothing but a social construct — and the ability of white people to oversee the atrocious genocide of red bodies, the destruction of black and brown bodies.

Only body trauma can explain how white people considered lynchings a form of entertainment. Only body trauma can lead white people to stop seeing people of color as human beings, and endorse and perpetuate wretched acts of violence against their bodies.

Menakem leads his readers toward authentic hope that we can — all of us, in different ways — overcome this legacy of trauma. But we can’t do it until we face it, and work with it, and teach our bodies to heal from it.

So: back to Mary of Nazareth, peasant girl, survivor of oppression, inconveniently pregnant in a time when such a pregnancy could mean her early death. (We also arguably live in a time like that.) Mary was the mother of Jesus. She blessed him with her trauma history, among other things, among other blessings.

Given what we know from the Gospels, those other things were lovely: she blessed him with courage, with gumption, with faithfulness. She was not a serene porcelain statue, but rather she bore in her body the kind of strength Michelangelo appreciated when he created the Pietà. Mary held her son’s body with her body, after his death: Mary was mighty. And so, in turn, was he.

But again, she had a hard time of it, given her social location. And so I think we can assert that she blessed him with the identity of an oppressed person, as well as the passion to stand up for other oppressed persons, and give his life away for them. She blessed him with resilience, with a spirit of endurance, perhaps also the spirit of serious engagement with and alongside humans in peril.

In John’s Good News Mary organizes the rescue of a couple and family from the debilitating social shame of running out of wine at their wedding party. That may seem like a trivial problem for us, but in that honor-shame culture, the family was about to be in extremely big trouble. Perhaps they would be ruined by such a serious social faux-pas.

And at that wedding she turns to — who else? — her son, born of her body, and conscripts him into service, blessing him with a sense of urgency and solidarity with his neighbors in need.

And so we praise Saint Mary today, not only because she is the Star of the Sea, but also because Mary the earthy mother blesses us with many of the powerful and provocative blessings she handed down to her son.

I believe Mary’s blessings are named in a prayer written by the Right Reverend Gene Robinson, a bishop who suffered plenty of trauma in his physical body. He led a blessing prayer just before the inauguration of a president whose black body was about to carry into public service an immense amount of courage, insight, and compassion, all of it grounded in generations of trauma suffered by his ancestors, on this land.

Here is Bishop Robinson’s prayer.

O God of our many understandings, we pray that you will…

Bless us with tears – for a world in which over a billion people exist on less than a dollar a day, where young women from many lands are beaten and raped for wanting an education, and thousands die daily from malnutrition, malaria, and AIDS.

Bless us with anger – at discrimination, at home and abroad, against refugees and immigrants, women, people of color, gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender people.

Bless us with discomfort – at the easy, simplistic “answers” we’ve preferred to hear from our politicians, instead of the truth, about ourselves and the world, which we need to face if we are going to rise to the challenges of the future.

Bless us with patience – and the knowledge that none of what ails us will be “fixed” anytime soon…

Bless us with humility – open to understanding that our own needs must always be balanced with those of the world.

Bless us with freedom from mere tolerance – replacing it with a genuine respect and warm embrace of our differences, and an understanding that in our diversity, we are stronger.

Bless us with compassion and generosity – remembering that every religion’s God judges us by the way we care for the most vulnerable in the human community, whether across town or across the world.

The sound of silence

Preached on the Eleventh Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 14A), August 9, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Stephen Crippen.

1 Kings 19:9-18
Psalm 85:8-13
Romans 10:5-15
Matthew 14:22-33

Walking on Water, by Alan Reed

I will begin with three little scenes, and one song verse, about silence. Silence in its many forms.

After the fire, [there was] a sound of sheer silence. When Elijah heard it, he wrapped his face in his mantle and went out and stood at the entrance of the cave.

From the works of Simon and Garfunkel:
Hello darkness, my old friend
I've come to talk with you again
Because a vision softly creeping
Left its seeds while I was sleeping
And the vision that was planted in my brain
Still remains
Within the sound of silence

From the novel “Franny and Zooey,” by J.D. Salinger:
You’ve even both been up here on many a weekend [since Seymour killed himself], and though we’ve talked and talked and talked, we’ve all agreed not to say a word.

After Jesus had dismissed the crowds, he went up the mountain by himself to pray. When evening came, he was there alone.

Here in this room, we attract an uncommonly large number of people who enjoy silence. They — we — might say that we find God in the silence. Or we hear God (ironically enough) in the silence. But if you don’t hear God in the silence, and especially if you feel anxious about that, as if you’re missing out, well, come sit by me. Often, often in our long liturgical silences, I need at least the first full minute to simply let my mind and heart catch up with my body. In our long silence after the second reading, my body has been in this room for some time — what, about twenty minutes? But my mind and heart are anywhere but here.

They are wandering downstairs, where there is always one thing or another thing to do. Or they are obstinately holed up in my office, fretting about who knows what, and honestly, who cares? The mundane worries and headaches of a working priest. Or my mind and heart haven’t even entered the building yet, because they are hovering in the skies over Minnesota, wondering about a member of my family, or they are poking around in my past, trying to find one of my parents, and tell them something I couldn’t tell them when they were in this mortal arena.

But then they finally catch up, my mind and heart, and they find me sitting over on that bench, in the silence; and they integrate with my body again, usually when I am gazing through those little clear windows at the tree branches in our labyrinth garden, or when I’m trying to breathe a little prayer for whoever is causing the blaring emergency vehicle to tear around the corner of First and Roy.

I wonder (I admit, with some envy) if some of you are masters of silence, old pros, able to gather mind, body, and heart into one cohesive being, right from the moment the silence begins. Maybe you are silence artisans, almost immediately tuning in. (Or is it tuning out? Do you expertly tune out all that is not relevant, all that does not matter, and listen in the silence for the life-giving heartbeat of your companion in the pew?)

I pray that each of us, the silence amateurs and the silence professionals alike, will be blessed by the experience the prophet Elijah enjoyed: he “heard” the sheer silence of God’s ineffable presence. He wasn’t daydreaming, or fretting. He was savvy: Elijah was not shocked that God wasn’t in all the expectable, dramatic places, the hurricane and the earthquake and the fire. Surely the terrible God of the Flaming Thornbush would, or should, thunder down upon us in a deafening and blinding theophany! But Elijah seemed instinctively to know better. He heard God in the sound of sheer silence.

Another translation says God was present in “a still, small voice.”

Then, in the wake of that silence, Elijah repeated his prayer to God, word for word. He may not have been changed or transformed by the divine encounter, but neither was he daunted. He stayed on point. Perhaps the silence gave him fortitude and courage.

I think Simon and Garfunkel would have gotten along with Elijah. In perhaps their most famous song, they do not celebrate silence itself, as if all we need to feel better about the world is some quiet time, but rather they lament how our noisy human world cannot hear the wisdom of the prophets, because that wisdom is whispered in the sound of silence, and we are too disconnected and distracted to hear it. We need to hear important things in the silence.

And as for J.D. Salinger, in his novel about a busy, brilliant, and traumatized family, he notes that they don’t talk about the devastating suicide of their eldest son and brother. Instead they “talk and talk and talk, and agree not to say a word.” They keep a dull and numbing form of silence you and I know well: the silence of idle chatter, the silence of our preoccupation with anything and everything except the thing we should really be talking about. An unconscious silence; a mulish or obstinate silence; an anxious silence. If God’s voice is in that silence, we will have a hard time hearing it over the white noise of our restlessness.

And finally today we step into a tossing boat, buffeted by high winds, and we see coming toward us that greatest master of silence, Jesus himself. Utterly in control, Jesus had dismissed the crowds and compelled his close friends to put out to sea, while he withdrew to pray in silence and solitude. Then, when he heard in his holy silence the cry of his friends, he brought his silence to them. 

Set aside for a moment the wondrous and bizarre part of the experience, when Jesus walks on water. More on that soon. Notice this first: when Jesus rescues Peter and they clamber back into the boat, this happens:

When they got into the boat, the wind ceased.

So: he had been alone on the mountain, where his compassionate ears heard their cry. Then he came to their aid, and brought his lonely mountain into their boat, a penetrating and calming silence. A silence that helped them settle, and listen, and move forward with confidence and purpose.

But he had to carry that silence over terribly rough seas. The bit about walking on water: Let’s consider that part of the Good News now. To our modern, practical ears, walking on water sounds absurd and fanciful, a fairy tale. But I encourage you to get quiet. Listen. Wonder about what’s being said here. Let go of literalism (as if this passage is a news article or a history piece), but also try to let go of your skepticism and cynicism. As you reflect, try to hear and see that Jesus is crossing the stormy seas of their doubts, their fears, their dashed hopes, their despair.

And as for Peter, once again the patron of fools who rush in where angels fear to tread: Peter actually demonstrates not just foolishness, but great courage by stepping onto the water himself, teaching us that even someone Jesus says has “little faith” can do brave and difficult things. This story of silence and storms, then, can reveal our own faith and courage, not just our weaknesses and our doubts. Today’s Good News reassures us that even if we have little faith, even if we feel weak, small, and afraid, with God’s help we will have enough. We will be enough.

Imagine someone crossing over the storms that rage in your anxious heart, and reassuring you that there is hope, and meaning, and a promise of a good future. Imagine him convincing you that your faith is enough, and your courage is enough, to meet and master the high winds of this troubled and traumatic age.

If someone actually got through to you and helped you calm down, and breathe, and dare to hope again, dare to trust yourself again, dare to trust the rest of us again, and dare to trust God again, well, that merciful gift might seem as improbable and miraculous as walking on water. But Jesus does it: he got through to them. He reached them. He sheltered them within his great silence. And today he walks over our own stormy waters, and shelters us.

Many years ago, Mother Catharine said something I remember quite fondly. Her words might illuminate all of this in a helpful way. We were talking about introverts and extraverts, as people in our time and place so often do. I prefer extraversion. Catharine prefers introversion. We were discussing how everyone needs silence for reflection, for balance, for insight, for courage. Not just introverts: we extraverts need the silence too. And Catharine said, “I actually think extraverts need it more, because introverts carry it around with us.” Yes, I like this. I quite agree.

Many of us (whatever our introvert/extravert preferences) have trouble carrying around the holy silence of God. God is with us all the same; I know Jesus loves me; I know the Lord is near. But sometimes we need the Silent One to come to us, and bring his silence with him.

Then, oh great relief, the wind ceases, and we receive all that we need to navigate this windy and storming world.

May the holy silence of God reach you. And may you have the presence of mind and heart to hear it, and wrap your face in your mantle, and stand at the entrance of your cave.

Congregant number 14

Preached on the Tenth Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 13A), August 2, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Stephen Crippen.

Isaiah 55:1-5
Psalm 145:8-9, 15-22
Romans 9:1-5
Matthew 14:13-21

Loaves & Fish, 5th century floor mosaic in the town of Tabgha

Last week, during the early mass, someone came into our church for a few moments, took one of the snack packs from the table near the baptismal font, and left. I saw this because I was up here, behind the table, getting our breakfast ready.

My immediate response was to add one to my headcount for that mass. “It’s fourteen now,” I told myself. And so that goes for a working priest who’s developing a Christian congregation in a mostly secularized urban setting: attendance is one of our lagging indicators, a metric that helps us assess the health and vitality of this congregation. I focus on attendance enough that I’ve been rightly teased about it.

But I like counting people, especially people I love. (And that definitely includes you, beloveds!) I’m from a big family, so I count my nieces and nephews, a daunting twenty-three people. I always try to count people and other creatures who matter. When I had a big aquarium in the kitchen during the pandemic years, I loved counting tropical fish. When I see videos of dog litters on the internet, I count the puppies. “That looks like seven,” I say to myself. One-two-three-four-five-six-seven. Yep. Oh wait, they’re squashing another one — it’s eight!”

But as far as the risen Christ is concerned, headcount seems unimportant. All four Gospels recount the story of the feeding of a multitude. (Matthew and Mark record two stories of dinner for a crowd.) In these six reports of Jesus as the one who feeds hungry humans, someone evidently does do a rough headcount. (“Oh, this looks like around 4,000 people, wouldn’t you say?” I can imagine a disciple musing during the messy distribution of fish and bread, and somebody saying back, “No, I think it’s 5,000, and that’s just the dudes!”). But Jesus himself makes no mention of numbers. He just insists that everyone have something to eat, and goes on to make that happen.

Jesus focuses on the people.

Jesus focuses on their hunger.

I think this is why, last week, after labeling that passing stranger our 8:00am-mass congregant number 14, I spent a little more time reflecting on him, and even praying for him.

This is always good to do — it’s good to reflect on how (and whether) we take care of our neighbors, and how (and whether) our care for them follows the example of Jesus Christ. Especially on Sundays, the day of Resurrection, the day when the one who fed hungry crowds on the hillside was raised from the dead.

Every Sunday, everything we Christians do is an attempt to re-enact the Resurrection, just as the first Christians did in the first household churches, at their Sunday dinner meetings. For Christians, every new week begins with Resurrection, and our forebears taught us that if, in our Sunday rituals, we are imitating the risen Christ, then we should remember that he appeared to them and shared food.

The risen Christ ate fish with his disciples, in their locked room. The risen Christ invited them to sit down for breakfast by the sea. The risen Christ was made known to two Sunday-evening hikers in the breaking of the bread.

The risen Christ taught his followers – before the crucifixion - that whenever they ate and drank together in a particular way, he would be with them.

And so we follow their lead and do this every Sunday. We break the bread, we pour wine into the chalice. We take care that everyone has enough. We look outward, into the pews, to be sure anyone who came here by wheelchair has been fed. Our table ministry also inspires us to set out more food downstairs, festive food, cheering food, cake and savory treats that improve your mood as well as nourish you. And we invite newcomers among us to join the feast. You all warmly welcome them to a round table and engage them in conversation. And if a neighbor comes down the ramp in search of life-saving food, or a blanket, or socks and other clothes, our neighborhood missioners usually notice and come to their aid.

All of this is encouraging to know, because honestly, I felt a little crestfallen when congregant number 14 stepped quickly into our entryway, took a snack pack, and left. It seemed a far cry from the explosion of wondrous bread and fish on the hillside, with all the crowds pressing in, and Jesus and his followers in the center, hurriedly gathering leftovers into baskets. I wished I hadn’t been so far away from our neighbor at that moment, and I appreciated the bitter irony of the fact that I was cut off from him physically because I was preparing our Sunday Eucharistic meal.

After all, this Table is our hillside, the hillside where we meet Jesus, the hillside where we are astonished by the depth of his compassion for the hungry crowd, the hillside where Jesus dispels scarcity anxiety and sets an abundant table bursting with life-saving food. This Table is where we gather a collection of funds, the funds from your own coffers that we use to purchase the snack packs, and the cans and boxes of food that fill our pantry. This Table is where we break bread that strengthens us for mission, a mission of feeding, clothing, and caring for human beings.

All human beings, mind you. There is only one thing we know about the crowd of 4,000 (or is it 5,000, or can we just set aside patriarchy for one second and count all the people, of all ages and genders, in which case we may be talking about some 15,000 people!) — anyway, there is only one thing we know about this crowd: they are all hungry. They aren’t all members of our clan, or our religion, or our political party. They aren’t all documented citizens of our nation. They aren’t all nice and kind, or smart and skillful. They aren’t all hardworking and virtuous. They don’t all have the same abilities or disabilities. Jesus has compassion on them, no matter who they are, and begins preparing the bread and the fish.

And so I wish I had prepared food for someone last week, not because I am Jesus (come on, now), but because we all are called to follow his lead. I wanted to say, I should have said, “Bring the snack packs to me,” and I should have welcomed congregant number 14 into the pews and made sure he got not just the food he anxiously found on our counter, but anything else he needed.

He might have had a job interview the next day: did he need a shirt or a jacket? He might have needed new socks or underwear: I felt so disappointed on a SPiN walk last month when we ran out of underwear moments before someone came up to us who was in desperate need of that one item. And of course he might have needed what almost all of us – I actually think every one of us – needs whenever we come into this room: he might have just needed to be looked in the eyes and greeted by another human being. 

Often, we Christians, in our effort to truly understand who Jesus is and what he is continually trying to teach us, imagine that Jesus himself is here in the room not just in the bread and wine, the Body and Blood, but also in the gathered assembly itself. “We who are many one Body,” a minister intones, and then we all say the response: “for we all share in the one bread.” The Body in that call and response is the Body of Christ: we who are many are one Body of Christ. And so we are. This is true.

Saint Augustine, when preaching about the Eucharist, says it this way: “Be, then, what you see, and receive what you are.” That is to say, “Be the bread and wine that you see; receive the bread and wine that you are.” Or said even better: “Be the Body of Christ that you see; receive the Body of Christ that you are.”

And so Christ overtakes the whole hillside, teeming with 15,000+ people, so many people we would drive ourselves crazy trying to get an accurate headcount. They all are drawn up into the Body of Christ. They all savor the fish and bread, and slake their thirst, and feel full, and ready to walk home, rescued from the peril of starvation for another night. And in this feast they become Christ himself: a Body broken for the hungry world; a Blood spilled out for the violent world; a sign of God’s abundant mercy in the cruel human arena. 

And so it is that I have found a new label for congregant number 14, who stopped in our building for only a minute or two, and probably felt nervous taking the snack pack. (I think I saw him look up anxiously at one moment, as if we would set food out for anyone else but him, mocking his hunger.) I have found a new identity, a new name, for this neighbor. And I pray that his new name will drive us even more energetically outward from here on the errand of the compassionate chef who founded the feast at this Table.

Congregant number 14 is, of course, the risen Christ himself.

The kingdom of heaven is like yeast

Preached on the Ninth Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 12A), July 26, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Kelly Moody.

1 Kings 3:5-12
Psalm 119:129-136
Romans 8:26-39
Matthew 13:31-33,44-52

Jesus and the parable of the mustard seed, artist unknown

The kingdom of heaven is like yeast.  

 In the first year of the pandemic, I had a dear friend here in Seattle who took up sourdough bread-making. I imagine you knew someone, or maybe you were someone who took up pandemic baking, too. Journalists suggested that we were drawn to baking bread not only out of necessity, but because it required mindfulness and physical touch, both of which relieved stress in an anxious time. As businesses closed and grocery shelves were emptied,baking bread grounded us in something ordinary and productive that met a need during a season of uncertainty. 

My friend’s sourdough hobby became so grounding for her that she baked nearly every day.  

Cinnamon rolls, delicious breads of every kind, you name it.  

Each day she dropped them on the porches of friends and family, who gratefully received them as the weeks went on. And all of this was possible because of a gooey yeast, a sourdough starter in a jar, shared with her by a neighbor who had gotten it from a friend, whose sister had given it to her.  This sourdough starter with a complex ancestral line sat bubbling on my friend’s counter more often than not.  It was honestly kind of unsightly.  In its gooey, bubbly form, it did not convey what it was capable of becoming.

 Today, Jesus compares the kingdom of heaven to yeast. Not to the transformed and completed loaf of bread or fine wine that the yeast can produce in time under good conditions, but the yeast itself.  The gooey, messy fungus that a woman ‘mixes’ or ‘hides’ into three measures of flour.

The connotation in the Greek is that no one knows it’s there, except the woman.¹  She plants it in the flour like a seed.  Yeast is a living organism, but it’s not a plant, and it’s not really an animal, either.²  Strains of yeast can travel through air, or grow in a jar like a sourdough starter, or ferment in a barrel of beer or wine.  They permeate and expand and decompose, transforming whatever host they’ve found in ways that scientists are still discovering. 

The kingdom of heaven is like yeast. 

Mycologists, the scientists who study fungi like yeast, admit that they do not yet fully understand all that these organisms are capable of. One evening during the pandemic, while enjoying our sourdough bread in the form of grilled cheese sandwiches, our family watched a documentary called “Fantastic Fungi.” We learned that there are three hundred miles of fungi growing under every footstep we take anywhere in the world.  We marveled at their vast thread-like connections underground, and their role in the endings and beginnings of nearly every living thing. Scientists have discovered that fungi can filter water and heal certain ailments, among other things. 

So if the kingdom of heaven is like a yeast, well, that is a metaphor worth exploring…a mysterious network of connections and processes still surprising scientists today. 

That’s what struck me as I considered this parable about yeast- the mystery is still unfolding. 

Joseph Campbell famously said “if you want to change the world, change the metaphor,³”  and Jesus offers more than one metaphor in today’s rapid-fire series of parables. 

But I think it would be all too easy to hear the parables Jesus tells this morning from the confines of our success-oriented, bigger-is-better culture,and only hear the message that greatness can come from small, humble beginnings.  That’s true, of course, but I think there’s something more nuanced and hopeful to unpack here, something deeper.  

After all, we do not really need a parable to tell us that God’s kingdom is mighty. 

We need parables to hold the mysteries of our faith…We need parables to draw us into stories that disrupt our easy assumptions and surprise us…. We need parables to remind us that the kingdom of heaven is growing in and around us all the time, like a common weed, or a jar of sourdough starter on a friend’s kitchen counter. 

We need parables to work on us, like a yeast works in flour, until there is enough room in our hearts and minds to believe that God’s heavenly reign really is mixed up and hidden in the messy, ordinary details of our common lives…and hidden in the unsightly places in our communities, too.  

Because that can be more difficult to believe, and frankly, more inconvenient. 

Jesus chooses images to describe the kingdom of heaven that point us toward an unfolding mystery rather than a linear progression of constant improvement.  Jesus invites us to see his kingdom working its way into everything, seeding our lives and our city with the presence of God…working toward a holy completion that can look like decomposing gooey yuckiness before it ever resembles a lofty loaf of bread. But when you know it’s there; when you know what it is, you don’t have to avoid it anymore.   

The kingdom of heaven is like yeast.  

Over the next few months, you and I will get to know each other as we pray and serve together in this beloved place, and I’m really looking forward to that.  I hope you’ll share stories about the places you’ve seen God’s kingdom unfolding here. I hope you’ll share about the practices of faith that anchor you in uncertain times. I hope you’ll share stories that are not yet finished, too, stories that may not yet reveal what we are capable of becoming. Because it’s in these messy, unfinished places that I believe Jesus is inviting us to meet him today to catch a glimpse of the unfolding kingdom of heaven. It’s in these vulnerable, uncertain moments that we are leavened with God’s love and sent out to share the good news that God’s reign prevails. 

________________________

¹ See A.J. Levine’s Short Stories by Jesus on the significance of translating the verb as “hides” rather than “mixes.”

² A quote from Fantastic Fungi

³ Quote shared here on StreetPsalms

Tending to the field

Preached on the Eighth Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 11 A), July 19, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by Laurel Tallent.

Isaiah 44:6-8
Psalm 86:11-17
Romans 8:12-25
Matthew 13:24-30,36-43

Sower with Setting Sun, by Vincent van Gogh

I am three generations removed from depending on my own crops. I have never planted a wheat field, I have not gone out to examine it, searching for evidence of ruin, and praying not to find it. Still, my very existence depends on the unseen labor of agricultural workers. Whatever distance we put between ourselves and the field, our shared dependence on agriculture gives us, and the first listeners of this parable, and millions of people in between, a common vocabulary for our most vital concerns. This parable is concerned with the persistent problem of evil, its presence in the world, and its destruction.

As with many parables, we approach it by asking “who is what?” Jesus identifies the field as the Kingdom of Heaven, and Matthew’s interpretation of the parable, following Jesus’ telling of it, casts other roles: The Chosen One, who we understand as Christ, is the farmer sowing good seed, the field is the world, the good seed are citizens of the kingdom, the weeds secretly sown in the field are the children of the evil one, and the enemy is the devil.

Let’s begin with ourselves: In this parable, we are the good seed, the wheat. I want to ground us in that identity because it is the first glimmer of the Good News in this passage, and it communicates the dimensions of the parable. We are wheat! And what does wheat do? Grow! That’s about it. The action in this parable is out of human control, outside of the sphere of our influence.

The good news is this: God has planted this field of good grain, and God is tending the field. Not only is God aware of Evil, it is God’s work to eliminate it. The day of reckoning is coming, and it is not your job.

I don’t think that I shirk responsibility, but I am relieved by this news. I can see that this is an untenable situation. The farmer’s work, if not wasted, has ballooned. The weeds growing among the wheat are horrifying, not only because they threaten the growth of the harvest but because of their indistinguishability. There’s a creepiness to that.

The Psalms and gospels provide us with a number of allegories where we are the sowers of seed. I like these images. They give me a sense of agency and purpose, and strengthen my convictions when the work of discipleship is hard. 

Their application is simpler: in the allegories where we are the sower, we are sowing seeds of the Kingdom when we love each other and God, when we feed and clothe each other, when we prevent or destroy the means of exploitation and abuse. When we do things within human grasp. This invasion of evil is not in our grasp. So it is good to hear: God will tend this field, burning the evil that inhabits the good world God has created.

This spring, I had the opportunity to attend a lecture on Karl Barth and the Problem of Evil at Virginia Theological Seminary, given by Dr. Sonderegger (a theologian who’s spoken at this pulpit, and received a lot of love from our rector). Barth, the subject of her lecture, was a Swiss Reformed theologian and contemporary of Bonhoeffer. One of Barth’s ideas about Creation is to reject a duality of Good and Evil, and consider a third way: there is God our creator who surrounds us and is with us always. There is all of God’s creation, present company included, named as “good” from the beginning of creation, but still fallible and mortal. Then, there is the nothingness of Evil.

In her lecture, Dr. Sonderegger emphasized Barth’s definition of evil: Evil is NOTHING, it is not created by God. Evil does not have the dignity of being created by God.

The weeds in our parable were sown by an enemy, they are not a part of creation. There are weeds in God’s field. Despite their nothingness, they are taking up space. If we consider the King James translation of this passage, these weeds are called “darnel, " a kind of ryegrass that hosts a toxic fungus that in turn infects wheat as well; an un-making of a harvest.

Evil, in its indignity, does not know Imago Dei. Evil does not know what it means to be made in God’s image, so it moves without care. I’m sure you have felt the edges of Evil in your life. It grows next to you and me and each of us. There is nothing you and I can do to stop it. 

Here again, is the Gospel Message: God will work the field and destroy the weeds. Beyond that, as we know and contemplate every Easter season, God has already tended to the field and burned the weeds. Evil has already been defeated. It was not created, but it has been unmade. The day of reckoning has already come. You and I, little stalks of wheat, might not feel that, but this parable assures us that is and will and has happened.

Both the reckoning and the weeds are beyond our perception. As wheat, we are never outside the field where Evil is planted, so it is impossible to have objective knowledge of it. But since many of us have been taught this parable as a way to sort good and evil people, I think we need to consider the identity of the weeds.

We were each created, sown, by the farmer of this field. When we indulge in the idea that some people are just evil, we are denying the work of God’s creation. We are surrounded by evil, we are choked and hindered by evil. We might be poisoned by evil. But you will be wrong every time you turn to a neighbor and name them “weed”.

We can see that Evil has infected the world around us. We witness human decisions that discard human life. We can see Evil so clearly that sometimes we struggle to recognize the humanity of tyrants through the dense growth of their evil choices. But we have failed to recognize evil, and we have misidentified it. Consider all of the times when the Church and her people have failed to discern correctly. We failed to recognize evil in slavery and racial bigotry, in empire and colonialism and a hundred other sources of marginalization and terror. We misidentify it in things that are new to us: Consider how we have challenged the goodness and legitimacy of every new letter added to the LGBTQIA acronym.  We routinely fail to see the harm that can come from our own good intentions, and we misunderstand other people’s motivations. I wonder what else we have misidentified, what we have not seen, or are incapable of seeing. So we continue to confess: We repent of the evil that enslaves us, the evil we have done and the evil done on our behalf. We are not capable of understanding the evil that surrounds us. We are not capable of tending the field that God has sown.

When we respond to our perception of evil, and rely only on our own understanding to destroy it, we will inherently create something too small, and too fallible. We will lose the path to something even more beautiful. If we respond to discord by striving for perfect agreement, we are rejecting Jesus’ invitation to build solidarity with each other. If we respond to violence with retribution, we are rejecting grace.

Even in allegories where we are the sower in the field, God is the one who brings the Kingdom that frees us. Even if you yearn for more or bigger work in this very broken world, I hope you see the liberation in that division of labor. We already have abundant work. 

In Madeline Miller’s novel exploring a female perspective on Greek myth, the titular character, Circe, chooses to become mortal after a truly harrowing life of immortal existence. Her son has died, and she has very few comforts except a loom that Daedalus built for her. In the closing chapter of the novel, Miller’s Circe considers a broken thread in her weaving, and reflects that she will content herself with “the quiet mending of the world”. She chooses a mortal-sized task as a mortal being. 

God will tend the field, now and forever. Thanks be to God. 

Embed Block
Enter a valid embed URL or code.

To walk in newness of life

Preached on the Seventh Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 10 A), July 12, 2026, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington by The Reverend Samuel Torvend.

Isaiah 55:10-13
Psalm 65: (1-8), 9-14
Romans 8:1-11
Matthew 13:1-9,18-23

Jesus Preaching on the Shores of the Sea of Galilee, by Abraham Willaerts

A few nights ago, my spouse and I watched the 2012 film, “Arbitrage,” a movie starring Richard Gere and Susan Sarandon – a movie in which Gere plays Robert Miller, the CEO of a Manhattan hedge fund, and Sarandon plays Ellen, his wife. [Spoiler alert!] As the film opens, Gere is on the verge of selling his company as he nears retirement; a company in which his daughter, Brooke, works as an accountant. What becomes apparent is this: the character played by Gere lives for one thing above all others, and that is the accumulation of wealth. “What makes you happiest in life?” asks a reporter. “Why, one thing,” says the CEO: “M-O-N-E-Y.” But, then, it becomes apparent that the CEO has engaged in fraud in order to sell his company. His daughter, the accountant, brings to his attention the fact that the firm’s financial books have been cooked – something he ignores to her consternation. He tells his wife and his adult children that he loves them and lives only for their welfare and yet we see that he has a much younger mistress named Julie upon whom he lavishes much wealth. While dozing off while driving Julie to an upstate cottage, his car slams into the railing, killing her, leading him to leave the scene of the accident in order to escape blame. He becomes desperate in his attempt to cover up his complicity in her death. And yet all of this – the fraud, the adultery, the lies, the evasion of responsibility – is treated as simply normal – as if such behavior is to be expected in the world in which we live, a world in which greed, lying, and unfaithfulness are ever present. 

It is this world that St. Paul speaks of when he discusses sin and the flesh, as he does in today’s second reading from his letter to the Romans. That is, when Paul speaks of sin, he is not talking about infractions of law or cultural custom, but rather about an energy field that pervades all cultures, an energy field that can be quite attractive yet one which distorts human life. And when he mentions the flesh, he is not – he is not – speaking about the human body, one of God’s gifts, but rather about the ego: the ego that lives for the self alone as if to live only for oneself were something quite normal, indeed something to seek, to admire. And it is this striving for the self alone – “It’s all about me!” – that permeates the energy field into which you and I have been born. That is, to live in the flesh is to live in the small self, the “self” trapped by the self, the ego that sees only itself. And thus this energy field easily leads one to welcome only that which serves the self alone: a sense of superiority to others; blaming others for one’s mishaps; the lust for wealth; always needing to win. 

Now, it’s not uncommon these days in some churches and in some communities to point to the current federal administration as a singular example of corruption, greed, and lying – and of its whole-hearted complicity in a narcissistic energy field. And perhaps there is truth in that claim. But to do so can lead us to imagine that the problem is “out there” and – if we only had another administration – all would be well. But Paul wants us to recognize that we are affected by this energy field that draws people into believing that they, that you and I, need nothing but the self – no real need for others much less for God – and that whatever serves the self – legal or illegal, ethical or unethical – is worthy of our attention and energy. 

I have a university colleague who is quick to say, and say far too frequently in my hearing – “It’s All Good; It’s All Good” – as if life is really a breeze, as if all we need is a good dose of “positivity” and everything will be well. And yet I wonder: Is it all good for the immigrant or person with brown skin who is persecuted by agents of the state? Is it all good for the millions of people in our nation, caught in poverty, who cannot pay both medical bills and food bills? Is it really all good for the 20% of children in our state who live daily with food insecurity, not knowing if they will have any food tomorrow? Is it really all good for the environment that continues to suffer from human arrogance? Is it really all good for those who live daily with racial or gender injustices? Is it really all good for women who continue to earn less than men though they are equally or better qualified? Is it really all good for the majority of Americans – over 60% - who experience chronic loneliness and a sense of isolation? 

In the midst of this not-so-good energy field and the temptation to care only for oneself, we are not alone, writes Paul. For there is another energy field available to us and the name of that energy is Jesus Christ, the One who divests himself of privilege, of being at the top, so to speak, in order to become one with us in his birth, public life, death, and resurrection. For you see, he does not ride above this world marked by outsized and even predatory egos to shower it with the fairy dust of “It’s All Good.” Rather he offers a far more life-giving yet challenging way of living, what Paul calls “walking in newness of life.” Well, that’s a lovely phrase, a compelling promise: to walk in newness of life. But what might that actually mean for you and me? 

Paul writes that to “set one’s mind on the flesh is death,” that is, to live in the small world of one’s ego robs one of that essential dimension of life which is relationship. To set the mind on the Spirit, he writes, is to be guided by the Spirit’s energy which is filled with life and peace: peace with one’s limitations, with one’s losses, with one’s mortality; peace with others – even the troublesome others; and certainly, peace with God. Thus Paul, our patron, sets before us the opportunity to live as the children of God: not with aggressive competition in which someone always loses but with mutual responsibility; not blaming others for our mistakes but admitting them honestly and seeking forgiveness; not hoarding our gifts and talents as if we alone created them but rather using them for the good of others.

The truth of the matter is this: we can never fully escape or transcend the energy field of the small self who serves the self alone and yet we can live into that energy which frees us from the toxic individualism so alive in our culture. Indeed, we can taste that life-giving and soul-expanding energy on our lips as we receive the Body and the Blood of the One in whom your large and generous self comes to life.